5 Best Dating Sites in Tallahassee

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 28, 2023
Couple dating in Tallahassee

After trying a few different options, I found that the best dating sites depend on what you’re looking for.

While some sites attract people who want to chat or meet someone casually, other platforms have users looking for something more serious.

Online dating is all about meeting new people and seeing with who you click. So why not do the same with dating sites and apps? It made sense to try a few options and see which platform was a good fit for me. Here’s what I found.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Tallahassee

Here’s my list of the best dating sites in Tallahassee.

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


With 5 million visitors a month, eHarmony is one of the most popular dating sites. Signing up takes a while, but I felt this process was worth it because a majority of the users take dating seriously and are ready to commit.

eHarmony is behind 4% of marriages in the US. It’s an encouraging number for those looking for a long-term relationship.

I wasn’t sure if eHarmony would be a good fit for me, but the site has a guarantee policy that convinced me to try it. If you’re not happy with the matches you get in the first three months, you will get three months for free.

I liked eHarmony because the matching system did a great job recommending profiles of users who had a lot in common with me. Plus, it was easy to find singles in my age range due to the large user base, and I also found users who were Christians.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Elite Singles is a dating site for educated people. I was worried about trying it because I thought the concept sounded a little exclusive and thought I might not fit in. This dating site turned out to be a pleasant surprise.

The site emphasizes education, but you can meet a wide range of singles who are educated and successful in their career.

This site matches thousands of couples every month. There is a very active community, and I liked being able to see new profiles every day.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

ChristianCafe.com is a faith-based dating website. I decided to try it to find people who share my values and beliefs. I highly recommend it to singles who want to meet someone who shares their Christian lifestyle and values.

I liked the quick match option because it’s a fast and easy way of finding relevant profiles. However, you can use some advanced filters to see more matches and can even save your search.

The profiles have a lot of information and include some questions about faith so you can find singles who share your views on religion.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

I loved the concept of SilverSingles. It’s one of the best dating sites for singles over 50. Unlike other dating platforms, this site is exclusively for those who are 50 or older.

I felt safe using this site because there are moderators who verify the profiles. Plus, there are some excellent filtering tools to find profiles that correspond to what you’re looking for.

I also liked how diverse and accepting the user base was. I chatted with singles who were divorced and widowed and got to know people I wouldn’t have gotten to know otherwise.

The drawback of SilverSingles is that the user base is small when compared to options like eHarmony.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Catholic leaders have endorsed this dating site, which made me want to try it. Catholic Match is very easy to use, and there is a large user base of people interested in faith-based dating.

The site lacks the advanced search features you can find on other platforms, but it remains functional. I liked the quick sign-up process because I was able to see matches within a few minutes.

I liked Catholic Match because there are many users over 50, and most of them are looking for a serious relationship.


It’s important to compare dating apps in Tallahassee to find one corresponding to the kind of online dating experience you want. Read in to learn more about different options.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

The most successful dating site is eHarmony. Because users have to buy a membership (free membership is also available with limited features) and fill out a lengthy questionnaire when they sign up, people who complete this process are more likely to be serious about dating.

More couples have met on eHarmony than on any other dating site, and it’s the dating site that leads to the most marriages. Plus, people who met on eHarmony are usually happier with their relationship.

What Is the Best Hookup Site in Tallahassee?

If you’re looking for something casual, Adult Friend Finder is an excellent way to meet other singles. This dating platform encourages users to be honest and open about what they’re looking for.

Plus, you can see matches that are sexually compatible with you after you answer a few questions.

What Is the Best Dating Site For Over 50 or Seniors in Tallahassee?

A lot of dating sites and apps tend to have a young user base. It can be challenging to meet someone if you’re over 50.

Silver Singles is an excellent option for seniors. This site is for singles over 50, and moderators verify that everyone meets this age limit.

You should also think about trying eHarmony. Because of the large user base, it’s easy to find singles in your age range. You can use the filters to explore profiles of singles over 50 or indicate the age range you’re interested in when answering questions to get matches.

Which Dating Site Is Best For Serious Relationships?

Again, I recommend eHarmony for serious relationships. It’s a site that has a reputation for helping people find long-term relationships. As a result, people ready to commit are more likely to sign up for this site.

Key Takeaways For Singles in Tallahassee

Tallahassee Skyline

Tallahassee is an exciting spot for nightlife and events. However, it can be challenging to run into the same people twice since there are many tourists and college kids.

There are singles clubs, events for singles, and speed dating options for those who feel adventurous. If that’s not your thing, online dating is a great alternative.

Is Tallahassee Good For Singles?

More than a third of adults in Tallahassee live alone, and only 30% of people are married. It means there are a lot of singles.

However, Tallahassee is a college town where 20% of people are between 20 and 24. The median age is 26. A lot of the local singles are young and might not want a long-term relationship.

Free Dating Sites in Tallahassee

Free dating sites are a good option if you aren’t sure whether online dating is right for you or if you would like to talk to other singles without being serious about finding someone.

The main issue with free dating sites is that few efforts are usually made to remove fake profiles and bots. Plus, these sites might not attract people who are ready to get into long-term relationships.

As an alternative to free dating sites, you should think about free trials. The five websites mentioned above offer free trials, so you can test them before deciding if you want to subscribe.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Tallahassee:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Click here for Jacksonville Dating Sites

Click here for Tampa Dating Sites

Click here for Miami Dating Sites

Click here for Orlando Dating Sites