5 Best Dating Sites in Jacksonville

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 28, 2023
Couple dating in Jacksonville

When it comes to the best dating sites in Jacksonville, some are better than others. If you’re trying to find a lifelong companion, there are options for different age brackets, religions, and even one with a guarantee! 

These dating apps in Jacksonville are all uniquely tailored to meet your needs and help you find a new life partner. Their algorithms help match you with people who share your values, goals, and hopes for the future. 

Top 5 Dating Apps in Jacksonville

Here are my recommended dating sites in Jacksonville:

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is the best of the best. eHarmony is for people who are sick of wading through the trash and people who are ready to find their match and begin an extraordinary love story.

It’s my number one choice for a few reasons, the first being that millions of people have found their soulmates on eHarmony! But, I love that eHarmony offers a guarantee: If you don’t like your matches in the first three months, they’ll provide another three-month membership for free.

eHarmony is perfect for people looking for committed relationships. Everyone on the site is ready to commit, so you no longer have to worry about pursuing people who don’t want to settle down.

eHarmony is also an excellent choice for seniors and Christians because they have such a large applicant pool. You can specify your matches’ desired age range and religious values, ensuring that you’ll only find compatible matches.

eHarmony gets the top spot because they have a guarantee, provides a platform for people ready to commit, and has the most extensive membership base.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Elite Singles is just that: A place to find the elite in the online dating world. The majority of Elite Singles users are well-educated, holding an undergraduate degree or higher. If having an educated partner is a priority for you, you need to explore Elite Singles.

Like eHarmony, members looking for love on Elite Singles are ready to commit. Not only will your potential matches be educated, but they’ll also be prepared for serious dating, marriage, and a lifetime of love and partnership.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Christiancafe.com is one of the top dating sites for Christian singles. In religious communities, it can be hard to find someone who shares your spiritual values, denomination, or commitment to your faith. Christiancafe.com makes it easy to filter out denominations that don’t align with your own, and you can specify your current engagement level with your church.

When it comes to using online dating, Christiancafe.com is the best dating app for Christians. The site boasts a large membership base, various filtering tools, and a very high success rate. If the options for marriage material at your church have dried up, take a leap and try Christiancafe.com!

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

SilverSingles is the premier dating site for seniors in Jacksonville. Their membership base is full of seniors who are single and ready to mingle! If you’re starting to lose hope of finding your perfect life partner, don’t let aging get in the way of your journey: try SilverSingles!

Despite reservations about online dating, SilverSingles boasts excellent user reviews, a high success rate, and a large membership base. When it comes to senior dating, it can be hard to find someone who meets your needs and shares your values. But, SilverSingles offers filtering tools to help you find the one.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

For Catholics in Jacksonville looking to find the perfect match that God made for them, look no further than Catholic Match. Dating in the Catholic church can be difficult, and you may feel like your only options are the singles in your local diocese. But, on Catholic Match, your possibilities are limitless!

Catholic Match isn’t just interested in helping Catholics find the one. They also encourage relationships and spiritual growth and offer tools to help singles become secure in themselves and their faith before committing to a life partner.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you know that you only want to use the best dating apps, but you’ve never used an online dating service before, the prospect of finding your soulmate online can be intimidating. 

While evaluating which dating site is right for you, you’ll probably have questions about success rates, hookup culture, and more. Let’s review some frequently asked questions about online dating at large.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony offers the best success rate out of all of Jacksonville’s dating apps. This success is likely due, in part, to both their large membership base and their guarantee of finding a great match. Millions of past users have said that their marriage wouldn’t have ever happened without eHarmony.

What Is the Best Hookup Site in Jacksonville?

If you cringe at the thought of commitment, or you need some time to sow your wild oats before hitting a dating site for committed relationships, you’re probably looking for a hookup site instead of a dating site. 

Luckily, Adult Friend Finder is an excellent choice for Jacksonville singles looking to hook up. Take advantage of their large user base, and put yourself out there! 

What Is the Best Dating Site for Over 50 or Seniors in Jacksonville?

Both eHarmony and SilverSingles are perfect for singles over 50 and seniors in Jacksonville. With its diverse population, Jacksonville offers a high volume of single seniors. But, it’s hard to find them if you’re not looking in the right places. 

SilverSingles is tailored explicitly to finding matches for people over 50, and eHarmony’s membership base features people of all adult ages. Either site would be perfect for someone over 50 looking to date in Jacksonville.

Which Dating Site Is Best for Serious Relationships?

eHarmony is the go-to dating site for people looking for commitment. In a world where it’s hard to find someone looking for a serious relationship, eHarmony has you covered. Everyone in their membership base is looking for their life partner, best friend, and the person they want to share every moment with in life. So if you’re looking for commitment, eHarmony is for you. 

Key Takeaways for Singles in Jacksonville

Jacksonville Cityscape

If you’re single in Jacksonville and the in-person dating pool seems to have dried up, you need to try online dating.

The best dating sites in Jacksonville listed above are guaranteed to help you find your person. So choose one that best represents your goals, needs, and values, and get started! Putting yourself out there by making a profile is the only way you’ll ever meet new people.

Is Jacksonville Good for Singles?

Jacksonville is a great city for singles. With its downtown scene, suburban living, and beach recreation possibilities, people of all ages flock to Jacksonville to live their best lives. And, the one is just waiting for you to find them! 

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Free Dating Sites in Jacksonville

If you’re looking for free dating sites in Jacksonville, don’t worry: All of the sites listed above offer a free trial period. Since you don’t have to pay just to try them out, what’s the risk? Try one, try a few, or try them all to start your online dating journey.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Jacksonville:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

It’s Time to Get Out There!

Now that you’re armed with information about the dating sites, it’s time to get started! Take the plunge, start a free trial of any of the sites above, make a profile, and move one step closer to meeting the love of your life.