5 Best Dating Sites in Sarasota

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 28, 2023
Couple dating in Sarasota

I remember when I had given up on the possibility of finding the right spouse. I had tried different dating apps, and all the people I met offered a difference of opinion or condition!

After months of fruitless searching, I realized I was searching for a spouse the wrong way.

I found it difficult to find love because I was exploring the wrong dating sites. For residents in Sarasota, there are various dating sites offering the promise of the best potential matches.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Sarasota 

While there are loads of legit dating sites available to residents in Sarasota, my top five picks are: 

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


At the top of my list of the best dating sites is eHarmony. eHarmony isn't a dating site where you join and wait for your match.

eHarmony is different from others in that the platform encourages users to be proactive. The platform spurs matches by teaching tips and giving directions to meet the best people.

The probability of getting a spouse on eHarmony within a short period is high. Every fifteen minutes, one person finds love on this dating site.

I especially recommend this dating site if you're looking for a Christian or senior for a long-term relationship. The dating website (also available via a mobile application) matches you based on your selected settings.
You can get matches by religion, location, and personal preferences, all of which you choose by yourself.

There are many things I like about the eHarmony dating site. But the most important is that the dating site is intentional about matching you with a spouse for a long-term relationship and marriage.

Another fantastic feature of eHarmony that I love is their guarantee deal! If you don't like the matches you get after three months, you'll get an extra three months without paying a dime! This feature indicates how much eHarmony trusts its platform to find your desired spouse.

When you join eHarmony, you'll have to answer profile questions, then upload at least three photos. You can upload up to twelve images! After that, you can start chatting with your matches.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


EliteSingles is an online dating platform existing in 25 countries worldwide, and 80 percent of its members have a higher education. One feature I love about this dating site is the consistent improvement in the matching process.

After signing up, you'll take a personality test that determines the type of matches you get. Here's where the improvement part comes in.

As much as EliteSingles cares about finding you a match, they want to find you the right match. From time to time, they remove inactive users and users with suspicious characteristics.

It's one of the dating apps in Sarasota that provides matches you can trust. Therefore, EliteSingles is for you if you're cautious about online dating.

With over 300,000 new members monthly, Elite Singles offers a decent dating pool for singles.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Specifically created for you to meet Christian singles, ChristianCafe.com is one of the top dating sites.

I particularly rate ChristianCafe.com because you can match with Christians within your current location or your current church denomination.

For instance, if you live in Sarasota and want a single Christian living nearby, you can tweak your settings to get matches that fit that criterion on ChristianCafe.com.

If you're looking to move to a particular country, you can find Christian singles in that country while living in Sarasota.

You can join ChristianCafe.com for a seven-day free trial. But if you add your photo, you get an extra three days for free. The free trial period enables you to use various features on the dating website and confirm their benefits.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Many of the dating sites in Sarasota and other locations hardly make room for singles above 50. I noticed that singles older than 50 find it hard to match their age group on most dating sites. That's why SilverSingles is on this list.

SilverSingles is a dating site that serves singles who have crossed the age of 50 years. Now, because people in this age group may get desperate for a partner, they get scammed relatively easily.

In a bid to curb these fraudulent activities, SilverSingles has steps in place to block and delete scammers before they can pry.

All you need to join SilverSingles is your email address and your answers to a personality test. The personality test influences the types of matches you'll get daily. In a day, SilverSingles will match you with between three and seven matches.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

From my experience, practicing the same religion as a potential match doesn't guarantee a relationship will work out.

In addition to religion, your beliefs and that of a potential match have to align. If you're a Catholic, CatholicMatch is the dating site for you.

CatholicMatch is specifically to help Catholic singles in Sarasota match with other potential spouses of the same faith. It may have started as a side project, but CatholicMatch has over one million users today.

Without joining CatholicMatch, you can do free searches based on your location. Likewise, every new member on CatholicMatch gets a free trial period.


Here's what you need to know:

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

With an average of 236 members getting married daily, eHarmony has the highest success rate amongst other dating sites.

What Is the Best Hookup Site in Sarasota?

For me, Adult Friend Finder passes as the best hookup site in Sarasota. 

What Is the Best Dating Site For Over 50 and Seniors in Sarasota?

In my opinion, SilverSingles is a great option if you're over fifty. But eHarmony has a larger population of seniors who need companions. If I were you, I'd try both!

Which Dating Site Is Best For Serious Relationships?

eHarmony is the best among all dating sites for people looking for a serious relationship in Sarasota.

Key Takeaways For Singles in Sarasota 

Sarasota bay at dawn

Like the story I described at the beginning of the article, getting a partner can be a very frustrating task. However, it doesn't mean your perfect spouse isn't out there!

Depending on the type of companionship you want, you can try out any of the five dating apps if you live in Sarasota and its environs. 

Also, don't rush your feelings with any new person you meet. Take the time to know prospective matches before making any commitments.  

Is Sarasota Good For Singles?

Did you think you were the only person single in Sarasota? You're wrong! Many people are looking for spouses in Sarasota, and trust me when I tell you that they live on the sites I have described above. 

Free Dating Sites in Sarasota 

Some dating sites offer free membership, while others run a paid membership model. Unfortunately, from my experience, the potential spouses you'll meet on most free sites are fake.

To prevent time-wasting, I've come up with a map that points you in the direction of the best dating sites in Sarasota. Time to open the door for love in your life!

Every single one of the dating sites I described has free trials and membership options. 

In most cases, dating sites that only offer a free membership have criminal elements as members! I think it's better to pay a token to find love than to lose money because of free membership!

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Sarasota:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

Final Words 

I faced many ups and downs during my search for a spouse on dating sites. From my experience, I have explained the best dating sites you can trust in Sarasota. 

If you join any of these dating sites, you'll have match options that'll suit your taste and religion! 

Good luck! By the next time I hear from you, you should be sharing your testimony.

Links for dating apps in nearby cities: