5 Best Dating Sites in Pennsylvania

By: Michele Baird
Updated: April 1, 2022
Couple dating in Pennsylvania

Looking for love in the Keystone state can be a daunting task. So I did some research and put together a list of the best dating sites in Pennsylvania, as well as some metrics to see how your town or city stacks up in the online dating world.

Are you looking for a long-term relationship? Are you a busy professional looking for a partner with a similar trajectory? Perhaps you’re looking for someone in your same age group or with your religious affiliation.

Whatever the case, I’ve found the right site for you to find what you’re looking for.

Top 5 Dating Sites in Pennsylvania

Let’s run down the top 5 dating sites in PA. All these sites offer mobile apps as well as traditional websites. Each one has some unique aspects to offer, but the best general dating site, eHarmony, gets the top spot.

1. eHarmony - Best Overall

eHarmony

Any way you look at it, eHarmony is the go-to site to find a quality partner for marriage or a long-term relationship. They’ve been making successful matches for over 20 years using data and methods curated by marriage counselors, psychologists, and relationship professionals.

Just look at the statistics. eHarmony has the highest number of matches that end up in marriage, the highest percentage of marriages from a dating site, and the lowest divorce rate of marriages from dating sites. To top it off, eHarmony offers a guarantee to find you a match!

Finding your match with eHarmony is easier done than said. The site is exceptionally user-friendly. It has a superb, highly intuitive mobile app. With over 37 million users, it’s one of the busiest dating sites around, and it’s free to join.

After making your profile, you will receive personalized matches immediately and daily until you find the one you’re searching for.

The magic in eHarmony is in its patented algorithm, which takes the guesswork out of finding compatible partners. You only see the people with whom you are ideally matched according to the system. This ensures that everyone you connect with is an excellent potential partner.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall

EliteSingles.com

Career-minded professionals are generally driven to excellence. That’s great for their careers, but it can play havoc in their personal lives. If you are a busy professional, you know this is true.

Maybe you’re on the 4th floor of the BYM Mellon center in Phila and looking up to get to the 40th floor. You don’t have much free time to find your partner to become the Dynamic-duo with. Elite Singles is where you see each other.

If you are a busy professional interested in finding a similarly motivated and like-minded partner, then Elite Singles is worth checking out. They cater to well-educated adults in white-collar professions (think lawyers, teachers, engineers, doctors, etc.)

Most people (80%) who use Elite Singles have at least a Bachelor’s degree, compared to the roughly 31% of Pennsylvanians who have one. For the professional corporate ladder climber and the 18-hour shift ER doctor, Elite Singles hits the mark perfectly.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

For those of you looking to find a partner match in the Christian community, you will want to look at ChristianCafe. The site has the Christian community and peoples’ relationship with Christ and Christianity at the center of its mission.

ChristianCafe also uses information like your denomination and level of involvement in the church along with the usual personality and preference type questions.

ChristianCafe has a 20+ year track record of connecting Christian singles with partners for friendship, communion, and marriage. This site also puts a stronger emphasis on company and community, so it’s suitable for more casual, spiritual connections.

Overall, a standout choice for those in the Christian community who want to find a like-minded partner.

4. Silver Singles - Best site for 50+ singles

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Jumping into the dating scene at any age is daunting, and it can be even more so for singles over 50. SilverSingles is for those of you who want to join a dating site designed specifically for the senior and mature singles community.

SilveSingles focuses on the issues and preferences shared by the older dating community. For example, they provide personalized expert help in creating your perfect profile and include a customer support center on-call to answer any questions.

The SilverSingles community revolves around fostering genuine relationships that range from friendship to life partnership and everything in between.

Matches arrive quickly and daily, and as mentioned above, customer support is always there to help make the experience an ideal one for you.

5. Catholic Match - Best site for traditional Catholics

Catholic Match

Catholic Match is tailor-made for people who want a traditional catholic relationship. If you are looking to have your Catholic faith as a foundation for a relationship, then this is the site to try out.

Catholic Match also asks questions that bring insight into a person’s relationship to the church and its teachings along with the legal personality and statistical questions. In doing so, they bring people together who share similar attitudes and practices regarding Catholicism.

Being grounded in the Catholic church means that Catholic Match cultivates a culture that stays true to its beliefs. They work hard to maintain that environment throughout the site.

It is also important to note that although it is based on traditional Catholic values, it does not exclude divorcees or practice more liberal forms of Catholicism.

If you are looking for that Catholic connection, this is one to check out!

FAQs:

Which site is best for finding serious relationships?

eHarmony is the best place to find a serious life partner for anyone looking.

If you are looking for a specific religious foundation for your long-term relationship, then also it's a solid option.

What is the best hookup site in Pennsylvania?

If you are looking to find a more casual experience in PA, Adult Friend Finder is a has-it-all site for adult casual encounters.

What is the best site in PA for senior or +50 dating?

Among all the sites I researched, SilverSingles and eHarmony come with the best place for you in the +50 crowd to find what you are looking for.

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

Once again, eHarmony comes away with the highest rate of relationships that go into marriage. It also has the lowest divorce rate for couples who met on the site.

Takeaways, Thoughts, Stats

Whatever kind of partner-in-crime you seek, these sites I talked about are worth a look. Whether you are in Pittsburgh or Scranton, Philadelphia, or Erie, you can find the one you are looking for.

Some fun stats:

  • Pittsburgh has been ranked 3rd best city in the country for online dating, while Philadelphia has crashed as low as #83!
  • Pennsylvania as a whole comes in at a respectable #11 for online dating
  • Approximately 29% of Pennsylvanian adults identify as single
  • Philadelphia wins for most usage by sheer numbers.
  • For the highest percentage, it's Erie.

The best news about all this is that it's easy to jump into Pennsylvania's online dating pool. 

Also Read:

Best Dating Sites in Philadelphia

Best Dating Sites in Pittsburgh

Free Dating Sites in Pennsylvania

eHarmony, EliteSingles, ChristianCafe, SilverSingles, and Catholic Match are all free to join, and they make it easy to get started with your search right away.

Take a look through these sites and find the one that speaks to your needs. Have fun finding The One!

Rank

Site

Free Trial Link

#1

eHarmony

Join for Free

#2

Elite Singles

Join for Free

#3

Christian Cafe

Join for Free

#4

Silver Singles

Join for Free

#5

Catholic Match

Join for Free