5 Best Dating Sites in Pittsburgh

By: Michele Baird
Updated: February 2, 2023
Couple dating in Pittsburgh

Are you looking to meet someone for a long-term relationship in Pittsburgh? Unfortunately, dating can be challenging, and with many dating apps available, you may find the task of finding the right dating site daunting and discouraging.

After working through many local and international dating apps and match-making companies, I’ve found a few great options to make it easier to find someone compatible.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Pittsburgh

Quality dating sites should be designed to give your search for romance and long-term relationships a significant boost. Here are the five best dating sites in Pittsburgh:

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


Why is eHarmony rated as the best dating site? The company has a high success rate of matching over 2 million people and focuses primarily on serious, long-term relationships, which is the members’ primary goal.

eHarmony offers a trial period, and monthly rates are reasonably priced and offer various features, including video dating.

eHarmony is my favorite choice for several reasons: the company offers a solid, consistent level of quality services to serious-minded people. The interface is straightforward to use, whether you use the desktop or mobile app.

The sheer volume of people available at any time makes the prospects great for meeting someone relatively quickly. Plus, it offers a guarantee that you’ll make a meaningful connection within three months of joining, or you will get another three more months for free.

The success rate is attributed to how accurate the matching process is, which considers specific groups and people, including seniors and Christians.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Elite Singles is an excellent choice for people with a professional career and higher education. I like the upscale platform and the commitment to inviting individuals focused on getting to know someone in a serious context rather than hooking up or playing games.

Are there any drawbacks? The membership price is a bit costly, though I think it’s a fair investment if you want to make a sincere attempt at finding someone for a long-term relationship.

Elite Singles lives up to its objective, so you’ll find quality dating here and avoid people who are looking for something casual. Like most dating sites, Elite Singles offers a free trial, so you can see if it’s a good option for you.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

ChristianCafe.com is an online dating service that specifically caters to singles of various Christian denominations. When I initially visited the site, I found that it was easy to navigate and understand the guidelines and expectations of the website.

One central theme of this match-making service, like eHarmony and Elite Singles, is the goal of long-term relationship and marriage. There is no room for casual hookups or similar arrangements, which ChristianCafe.com strictly forbids. 

The dating site is open to divorced and widowed singles, as well as people looking for friendship. I think this dating site is great for anyone looking for someone who shares their faith and takes a long-term commitment seriously.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Many dating sites cater to a demographic between 25 and 50, while Silver Singles is specifically for singles over 50.

I like the laid-back nature of this site, which offers a great platform to sign up and create a simple profile before you complete a comprehensive assessment to help match you with the right person.

While you can sign up for free access when you join Silver Singles, you’ll need a paid membership to send and receive messages, the ability to post comments on profiles, and receive extra matches.

I like the mobile app feature, which is convenient and makes it easy to chat or connect with other singles on the go.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Suppose you’re looking for a dating site that focuses on singles who practice the Catholic faith.

In that case, this match-making service offers a specialized platform for devout Catholics and people taking serious steps towards practicing the faith to find someone who matches their personal and spiritual goals.

This dating website aims to find a match for a long-term commitment, leading to marriage. It’s the largest Catholic-only dating service that offers some unique benefits. If you don’t find a match within the first six months of your membership, CatholicMatch will offer you another six months for free.

It takes about 30 minutes to complete your profile, which can also be connected to Facebook.


Below, find answers to some of the most common questions when it comes to dating sites:

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

One of the oldest and well-established dating sites, eHarmony is one of the best dating sites in Pittsburgh. It offers a premium service that costs a bit more than most companies, though you’ll gain access to an extensive network of singles. 

eHarmony conducts thorough reviews of each profile, which is essential in avoiding fake profiles and people who aren’t serious about dating.

What is the best hookup site in Pittsburgh?

Adult Friend Finder is our recommendation. It offers an excellent interface, a compatible mobile app, and video chat is also available. Since the company has been around for a while, it’s had a long time fine-tuning many features. 

The dating site continually improves over time while keeping some familiar attributes. 

Overall, I think it’s a decent website for various hookup relationships and offers some flexible choices, though primarily focusing on short-term goals.

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in Pittsburgh?

I recommend eHarmony and Silver Singles as the best dating apps for seniors. 

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

I recommend eHarmony as a top choice for high-quality online dating. 

The company has a proven track record for carefully monitoring profiles, providing adequate support, and a reasonable cost for all members. The dating service has come a long way in providing competitive services for singles locally and internationally.

Key Takeaways for Singles in Pittsburgh

Night view of Pittsburgh

I like the idea of getting in touch with individuals whom I wouldn’t normally encounter in everyday life if it wasn’t for the convenience of match-making services.

Dating sites sound like a great way to make friends, and they’re geared towards casual fun and meeting people in your area of Pittsburgh. 

These dating apps are a way to find someone for hookups, sexual encounters, and exploring the swinger community.

You can meet people online for some virtual play or join these websites with over 50 million members. It’s a quicker way to meet someone, unlike dating websites focused on long-term commitments that may take months to find a good match.

However, it’s a great way to let loose and explore the possibility of fulfilling a much-awaited fantasy and sharing more explicit photos and messages not permitted on other dating sites.

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Most Popular Dating Apps in Philadelphia

Free Dating Sites in Pittsburgh

Dating sites have grown to encompass a wide selection of communities and specialized matches, from faith-based dating services and long-term relationships leading to marriage to hookup dates, swinger lifestyles, and casual friendships with benefits. 

While many dating sites feature specific communities and singles with shared interests and common relationship goals, eHarmony is the best choice overall for quality singles. This well-established online service features some of the highest success rates in the country.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Pittsburgh:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match