5 Best Dating Sites in Columbus

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 30, 2023
Couple dating in Columbus

Let’s face it. COVID-19 has forever changed the way we approach dating. Of course, you want to go out and make a special connection, but you also want to follow appropriate guidelines. Maybe now is the time to see what online dating has to offer you.

Meeting and vetting other singles online is the best way for you to be social and find possible connections. Whether you are looking for a fun weekend fling or a relationship with more possibilities in Columbus, read on to hear about the five best dating sites in Columbus.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Columbus

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is the best option for singles of all ages. eHarmony works because they believe the requirements for lasting, committed love are compatibility and connection.

Your personality profile and compatibility quiz (with 29 dimensions) both help when determining your matches. eHarmony also offers pro-tips to help you put together a unique snapshot.

A whopping 29% of users are 55+, giving older singles a fighting chance at finding love. The user-friendliness of the site is often a big plus for mature members of the community.

eHarmony is also popular amongst Christian singles. eHarmony appeals to them because of the high numbers of Christians who already use the service. Interestingly, not being solely Christian-based is also appealing to many of the Christian users.

To help their clients stay safe, eHarmony now offers a valuable feature to Premium members, video dates. They are a great way to help ease into a friendship.

Once you have exchanged a few messages with someone, the option to go on a virtual first date will be available. Such a service can help take some of the stress out of that first meeting.

eHarmony offers a generous guarantee. If you have not found a mate after three months of genuine effort, they will give another three months membership for free. Make sure you have chosen a 3-month or more subscription to have this option.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


While eHarmony appeals to a wide range of the population, Elite Singles focuses on attracting a more narrow range; educated professionals. They boast that 85% of their members have Bachelor’s degrees or higher.

With 90% of their users over 30 years old, there is little attraction for young and less educated individuals. Elite Singles has honed in on their demographic and are serving them well.

Like eHarmony, Elite Singles offers tips for creating your profile. They also provide profile checks, a security protocol that happens daily.

Their regional dating guides are helpful when you are dating someone in an unfamiliar city.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

If finding someone who shares your faith is at the top of your priority list, Christian Cafe may be worth checking out. They are proud to be responsible for more than 25,000 marriages since 1999.

Despite not having near the numbers as eHarmony, Christian Cafe offers something unique from other dating sites.

The website provides forums and chat rooms. Through group conversations, members get to know each other in an organic and supportive setting.

Christian Cafe also offers a generous 10-day free trial.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

For anyone over 50, Silver Singles provides matching services and profile tips. Their personality test helps find compatible singles for you to meet. You get 3-7 potential matches each day.

On the homepage, they emphasize the importance of up-to-date website security and excellent customer service. Despite all of that, there is a distinct lack of bells and whistles.

Silver Singles is straightforward, no-frills online dating for people who are done with all of that malarkey anyway. 

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Catholic Match is for singles who have specific religious-based requirements for a mate. At Catholic Match, sacramental marriage is the ultimate desired outcome.

It’s unclear if there is a specific process used to make their matches. The website provides what they call Faith-Focused Dating. Their platform brings Catholic singles together who would not have otherwise met.

Even though there are no fun quizzes to take, there is a full page of endorsements from leaders in the Catholic community.

Catholic Match also offers a similar guarantee to eHarmony’s; after six months, you get the next six for free.


Which dating site has the highest success rate?

With users that number in the millions, it’s clear eHarmony has the highest success rate amongst the best dating sites. If you live in a metropolitan area, like Columbus, you will find plenty of other people who have also made the eHarmony commitment to finding a mate. 

What is the best hookup site in Columbus?

Our list of dating apps in Columbus doesn’t offer an appropriate choice for finding hookups online. Instead, check out Adult Friend Finder. AFF is a decidedly sex-based site, providing a variety of hookup options and places for swingers to swing. 

What is the best dating site for singles who are 50+ in Columbus?

eHarmony is the top choice for those over 50 who want to see many potential matches in their inboxes. Silver Singles provides a pared-down platform for people who don’t need frills.

Which dating site is best for finding serious relationships?

Unless you are looking for tawdry hookups or sacramental marriage, eHarmony is your best bet for finding a serious relationship. With lots of potential matches, chances to meet via video, and a genuine guarantee, eHarmony is the best choice.

Takeaways for Singles in Columbus

The Scioto River and skyline at night in Columbus

Columbus is the third most populated capital in the nation. A dating site like eHarmony can help you navigate a well-populated dating pool. 

Start with some video dating to stay safe. Try each of you going to a favorite outside spot and giving your date a virtual tour. 

When both of you are ready to meet in person, have a snack at peaceful Alum Creek Beach or a stroll through cobblestoned German Village.  

Is Columbus Good For Singles?

Being both the capital and county seat means Columbus is a bustling city. Columbus is also a city of industry, including technology and energy, defense, and medical research. 

All of that activity makes Columbus a good place for singles to meet other singles.

With a mean age of 32.2, Columbus is great for singles in their 30’s. There are, however, plenty of opportunities for singles of all ages in Columbus.

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Cleveland Dating Apps

Cincinnati Dating Apps

Free Dating Sites in Columbus

These dating apps in Columbus are even better considering that they are free upon signing up. You can sign up for eHarmony at no cost to you. Do your compatibility quiz and familiarize yourself with the site, but you will have access to limited information for potential matches. 

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Columbus:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

Similar to eHarmony, Elite Singles lets you sign up for free and start experiencing their site. Additionally, you can sign up for a paid membership and get access to all premium services. If after three days you are not satisfied, you can receive a full refund.

ChristianCafe.com offers a full 10-days of free access to their site. You can participate in a few forums or chat rooms and take a deep dive into what they have to offer.

SilverSingles technically has no free trial offer. Like the others, they allow potential members to check out the site and do some fun and insightful personality tests.

Catholic Match offers both premium and non-premium accounts. They don’t offer a free trial, but the free option gives you access to messages and profiles.