5 Best Dating Sites in Cincinnati

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 30, 2023
Couple dating in Cincinnati

When I first started dating the “old-fashioned” way, the first few dates were tedious and nerve-racking. All the conversions felt like a job interview. I had to decide on compatibility first. Also, my options were limited because I did not know many people in the city.

If you use the right online dating site, the interview and compatibility are done for you. First, you fill out a questionnaire. Then, the site uses algorithms to match you with someone who has the same interests as you.

In a large city like Cincinnati, the odds of running into your soulmate at the store, bar, or club are low. However, the best dating sites significantly increase your odds of compatibility.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Cincinnati 

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


My first choice is eHarmony. eHarmony has the most extensive compatibility questionnaire. That questionnaire weeds out people that don’t fit with what you want in a partner. Over two million people have found love on eHarmony.

eHarmony is the most recommended site, even if you want to meet only Christians. If you are a senior citizen, eHarmony will work great for you as well. It has the highest number of users, so there really is someone for everyone on eHarmony.

There is data to prove that eHarmony leads to the highest amount of serious relationships and marriages than any other dating site. They boast over two million messages a week. Site users discover their love every 14 minutes.

Many sites are designed for a specific religion or age group. eHarmony welcomes all singles, no matter your age, religion, race, or sexual orientation.

These methods work. If they don’t work for you, eHarmony offers a money-back guarantee. I guarantee you won’t need to get your money back.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Elite Singles is a dating site for people with higher education. Most members of this site are over 30. Most of them also have more than average education.

Thousands of people have found a serious relationship each month on Elite Singles.

This site offers dating advice for professionals from 30-55 that they service. They offer you three to seven options a day using location, education, and preferences as a guide.

They delete inactive users and allow people of different races and creeds on the site as well as gay members.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

ChristianCafe.com is a dating site designed by a Christian couple to help Christian singles for a God-centered relationship. They have produced over 25000 marriages for site users.

ChristianCafe also offers online forums to build a sense of community. Many of these forums help Christian singles dive deeper into the thoughts and ideas or those they may politically date.

Like other dating sites, they do personality profiles to set up matches, but they go deeper into your faith as well. You also tell them what denomination you are, your level of faith, how much or little you are involved in your church activities, and other relevant faith information.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

You must be 50 years old or older to join Silver Singles. They have a simple and easy-to-use platform. All you need to start is to enter an email address.

You fill out an in-depth personal profile. Your personality test, along with your goals, values, and other criteria, you enter to create your matches. They send you three to seven local matches a day.

The Silver Singles web set can help you create a good dating profile. They also have a full-service customer service team on hand to create a safe and appropriate dating environment. The customer service team can also help with questions you may have about the site.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

This site is to help single Catholics find love with another person with a good Catholic foundation. You find your true partner that leads to a sacramental marriage.

Catholic Match is the most popular Catholic dating site with the most members.

The site is designed to help single Catholics find the person God intended them to marry. Catholic singles use the site all over the world.

Many Catholic leaders have endorsed this site due to its high level of successful relationships and marriages. Some of these leaders have found their spouses on this site. Other leaders hear success stories from their congregations.


Which dating site has the highest success rate?

Sites like Silver Singles and Elite Singles have high success rates among their users. However, both of those sites are calibrated for a specific group of people. If you do not meet those parameters, you will have no success. 

The site with the highest success rate for users everywhere is eHarmony. It has produced the most successful, long-lasting relations overall. It has the most users and no specific parameters that lower your match pool. 

eHarmony uses scientifically proven personality matching methods to create their success. 

What is the best hookup site in Cincinnati?

Adult friend finder is the best hook-up site. It is designed so that you can meet people just for casual sex. They allow uncensored pictures on the site. There are plenty of erotic stories from adult users. 

This site links you by your sexual profile to others looking for the same things as you. This is a great site for swingers.

What are the best dating sites for over 50 or seniors in Cincinnati?

Silver Singles is a great site to meet people in your area over 50. It focuses on local seniors and has a user-friendly website.

eHarmony is also a great site. It has the highest number of users, giving you a bigger pool of potential dates to choose from. The sight is also easy to use with the highest success rate overall. 

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

eHarmony is the best site to find a serious relationship. The site is specifically designed to cultivate serious relationships. It has led to the highest number of successful marriages of all dating sites.

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Columbus Dating Apps

Most Popular Dating Apps in Cleveland

Free Dating Sites in Cincinnati

Cincinnati in Ohio

All of the dating sites mentioned above have a free trial. Most free trials are 10 to 14 days. That is sufficient time to compare the quality of these sites with ones that claim to be completely free. 

Dating sites that don’t charge are usually unregulated and don’t create great matches. The personality tests are generally generic in nature and will have as accurate a picture of who you want to date.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Cincinnati:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

Final Words

Cincinnati is a larger city, so finding a date can be hard. However, with the internet and online dating, finding the right person is easy. Dating apps like eHarmony make the city much smaller.