5 Best Dating Sites in New York

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 20, 2023
Couple dating in New York

New York is one of the most exciting states in the US, including the dating scene. I’ve used multiple dating apps in New York and finally found the best ones to find that special person.

However, not all dating sites are for everyone depending on your age or interests.

Read on to find out more about the best dating sites in New York.

Top 5 Dating Apps in New York

I’ve compiled the top 5 dating sites after testing countless apps in New York, including the most populated cities. 

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is one of the most well-known dating apps in the US, as it has a high success rate amongst singles of all ages and backgrounds.

If you’re lonely in New York and looking for a serious relationship, consider eHarmony. Also, many marriages have formed after millions have used eHarmony, making it a dating app best for those looking to tie the knot.

eHarmony has several features to match you with your potential life partner with a compatibility test where you answer over 100 questions. From there, you are matched with people who have the same interests and life goals as you.

Lastly, eHarmony offers a guarantee, giving you the confidence to find a match in the Big Apple.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


If your career and education are important to you and your potential partner, consider Elite Singles.

This dating website caters to those with an “above-average” education, such as a graduate degree or even a post-doctorate.

Elite Singles also caters to singles over 30 years old who are ready for a serious relationship. The dating app uses an algorithm to deliver active singles based on your preferences, with the site stating they have a high success rate.

In New York, about 36.6% of the population over age 25 has a bachelor’s degree or higher, making Elite Singles a must for those searching for highly-educated people.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

About 60% of adults in New York are Christian, making ChristianCafe a top choice for Christian singles who are serious about their faith and want the same in their lover.

ChristianCafe has over 3,000 testimonials with happy couples finding love on the dating website. Also, they’ve mentioned 25,000 marriages have resulted from their dating app, making it highly successful.

Also, if you’ve divorced and are looking for a devout Christian who may be in the same situation, ChristianCafe is a top choice.

ChristianCafe.com is best for older age groups, such as 35 to 49 and over 50, although 25 to 34-year-olds are active.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

New York has about 7 million people over age 50, with 19% single men and 24% single women. Silver Singles is an excellent opportunity to find older singles in New York, particularly New York City.

This dating app also makes it easy to find older singles by taking a personality test. Silver Singles then matches you daily with new potential partners based on your answers. You can also browse by city or zip code to find other singles near you.

Whether you’re divorced, never married, newly single after a long relationship, Silver Singles is excellent for all backgrounds, sexes, and sexual orientations.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

In New York, particularly New York City, about 33% of the residents are Catholic, making it one of the largest Catholic cities in the US.

Catholic Match is a faith-based dating website endorsed by Catholic leaders, giving you opportunities to find a match with someone who shares the same morals and faith as you.

On Catholic Match, there is a breakdown on singles matches for everyone, such as:

  • Over 50
  • Traditional
  • Young Adult
  • Hispanic
  • Conservative
  • Liberal

Overall, Catholics in NY with varying beliefs and ages can find a partner on Catholic Match, based on its success, testimonials, and functionality to help find potential matches.


Which Dating Site is Best for Serious Relationships?

eHarmony is the best dating site for serious relationships in New York. It has a proven track record for singles, including newly divorced people looking to find love again.

This dating app is also suitable for most age groups, especially those over the age of 35.

eHarmony is also great for most age groups and is also female-friendly due to its safety features. Also, you can chat and even video call matches to ensure they’re a real person before meeting up.

What is the Best Hookup Site in New York?

Adult friend finder is the best hookup site in New York. Not only is it excellent for casual meetups or finding friends with benefits, but all lifestyles are also welcome, such as fetishes, kinks, and swingers.

What is the Best Dating Site for Over 50 or Seniors in New York?

Silver Singles is the best site for seniors in New York or those over 50. The site offers a free trial to browse singles and find potential matches without committing. However, you must pay to begin chatting with locals over 50.

Silver Singles is safe and secure, offering seniors the opportunity to find love again after divorce or even for the first time. All ethnicities, backgrounds, and sexual orientations are welcome to join the site and find a partner in New York.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony has the highest success rate amongst most age groups and backgrounds. Because of its intelligent compatibility tests, you find potential matches based on your preferences and goals. As a result, you spend less time browsing and more time chatting.

For those looking for highly educated partners, Elite Singles also has a high success rate. Elite Singles also has an algorithm to match you with others based on goals and what you’re looking for in a partner. It’s also ideal for those over the age of 30.

Key Takeaways for Singles in New York

Panorama of New York

Now that you’re aware of the best dating sites in New York, here are a few takeaways:

  • There are 51.4% females and 48.6% males in New York
  • 38% of residents have never married, 9% are divorced, and 6% widowed
  • New York is amongst the top three in single men between the age of 18 to 39.

Is New York Good for Singles?

Yes, New York has a handful of cities that are great for singles. Besides New York City, which has a population of over 8 million, there are smaller cities that also have lots of single individuals, including:

  • Ithaca
  • Rochester
  • Upper East Side
  • Lower East Side
  • Astoria
  • Spring Valley
  • Troy
  • Buffalo

What City in New York is Online Dating the Most Popular?

Online dating is most popular in the largest metropolitan area of New York, which is New York City.

With about 8.3 million people, many singles are looking for love, especially amongst young adults. 

However, New York City dating is known to be competitive, which is unusual. That’s why it’s important to use a successful dating website to find those who are serious about dating and may have the same interests.

Free Dating Sites in New York

All the websites mentioned in this article offer a free trial, meaning you can try the dating apps without paying. You can browse singles and potentially chat with people in your area without committing.



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match