5 Best Dating Sites in NYC

By: Michele Baird
Updated: March 17, 2022
Couple dating in NYC

Dating in NYC can be challenging, especially if you are looking for a serious partner. If you’re a senior or a Christian, dating can be even more difficult. While many dating apps are on the market, many gear towards short flings, one-night stands, and the younger crowd. 

I know how frustrating that can be, which is why I compiled a list of the five best dating apps in NYC. If you’ve been looking for paid or free dating sites that work, this article is for you. 

Top 5 Dating Sites in New York City 

Below I’ve compiled a list of the top five best dating sites and apps for you to check out if you’re looking for connections. 

1. eHarmony - Best Overall

eHarmony

Many things make eHarmony my #1 choice for dating, and one of them is its guarantee. 

It’s not often that a dating app will make some kind of guarantee that you’ll find love — but eHarmony is confident enough in its services that it does. 

Here’s how the guarantee works: Sign up for three months of membership at eHarmony. If you aren’t satisfied with your matches, they’ll give you another three months for free. 

eHarmony is also one of the best dating sites for seniors, as it has a large user base of seniors compared to other dating apps. Indeed, many dating apps gravitate towards the younger crowd only. 

In addition, eHarmony has a lot of Christian users, so if you’re looking for a Christian partner, it’s a great choice as well. There are some other great Christian dating sites, but eHarmony is one of the largest sites overall. 

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall

EliteSingles.com

Elite Singles is a serious dating app with a focus on educated singles who are looking for love. It uses an intelligent algorithm to suggest matches for you, based on what you’re looking for in a life partner. 

Elite Singles is also suitable for Christian dating and dating over 50. Single parents and many others can use Elite Singles to find a life partner as well. 

According to Elite Singles, over 90 percent of users on the platform are over 30 years old and have an above-average education. If that sounds like you, then Elite Singles might be the perfect platform to use. 

It even gives you expert profile advice to help you craft the perfect profile and increase your chances of success! There are also many articles on topics such as the best date ideas in NYC. 

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

ChristianCafe.com has been around since 1999, and it’s helped many people find Christian life partners. In fact, it’s led to over 25,000 marriages! 

There are over 3,000 client testimonials from happily-married Christians. 

While many people have found local life partners, others have found love across the country and later moved to be with each other. Think of it as a virtual singles’ event for Christians at a virtual cafe. 

You can get started on ChristianCafe.com for free — just sign up for the free trial to check the site out. Start messaging other Christians and see where it takes you!

ChristianCafe.com isn’t only for people in the US. If you’re interested in finding a foreign partner, you can find Christian singles in many other countries, including Russia, Peru, Japan, and more!

Are you looking for a life partner from the same denomination as you? ChristianCafe.com has you covered — for example, you can meet other Coptic Christians. 

Other denominations you can find on ChristianCafe.com include: 

  • Seventh-Day Adventist
  • Orthodox Christian
  • Quaker
  • Anglican
  • Apostolic
  • Born Again
  • Mennonite
  • Evangelical
  • And more

If you are non-denominational, don’t worry, as there’s a section for that too. 

ChristianCafe.com is owned by Christians, for Christians. 

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Are you tired of signing up for dating sites but not finding anyone your age? If you’re over 50 years old and looking for someone to share your life with, try out SilverSingles. 

SilverSingles is exclusively for those 50 years old and older. As you can expect, most people on SilverSingles are looking to date seriously, but you can find a more casual partner there as well. 

There are all kinds of people on SilverSingles, including many who are dating after a divorce. 

When you sign up on SilverSingles, it will ask you to take a personality test. The personality test is a bit in-depth, but it’s worth taking. 

That is because it will help you get more accurate matches - the site will show you up to seven selected matches for you every day, based on your profile and what you’re looking for in a partner. 

On other dating sites, you may be able to filter by age range, but SilverSingles is one of the only sites exclusively for people over 50. 

Don’t worry; SilverSingles is safe to use. It uses SSL encryption, fraud detection, and a robust reporting system to ensure your data is secure and that you feel safe while using the site. 

SilverSingles provides some great profile optimization advice as well. 

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Finally, the last dating site on my list is Catholic Match. As its name suggests, Catholic Match is for Catholics who are looking for other Catholics to date, marry, and settle down with. 

It’s the most prominent Catholic dating site globally, making it your top choice if you’re a Catholic. It is built on strict Catholic guidelines.

Unlike many dating apps, Catholic Match is not for hookups or short flings. It’s for serious Catholics looking for a serious life partner.

It even offers a guarantee of six months of free membership for those who put in a serious effort during their first six months on the site. 

FAQs

Which dating site has the highest success rate? 

eHarmony has the highest success rate. If you’re looking to find a serious partner, eHarmony should be your top choice — it’s full of other people also looking to date seriously. 

What is the best hookup site in NYC?

What if you want to hook up and not date seriously? The apps in this list might not be for you. 

Instead, you’d be better off using Adult FriendFinder. Adult FriendFinder is a website for those looking for casual hookups, friends with benefits, and short flings. 

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in NYC? 

eHarmony and SilverSingles are the best dating sites for 50+ dating in NYC. SilverSingles doesn’t have anyone younger than 50, so you won’t have to worry about finding someone too young for you. 

On the other hand, eHarmony has a more extensive user base, so you might have a better chance of success on that platform. While not 100 percent perfect (as some people put their age wrong), the age filter on eHarmony works pretty well. 

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

For serious relationships, I recommend eHarmony. Stay off hookup sites and swiping apps that have people looking for hookups, and use eHarmony instead. 

People on eHarmony are looking for serious relationships, just like you. 

Key Takeaways for Singles in NYC

Fortunately, there are many ways to find love in NYC, straight from the comfort of your home. You can find your life partner while on your computer or phone, even if you are looking for a Christian wife or husband or someone over 50 years old. 

Use one or more of these five dating apps (depending on your needs) - you’ll thank yourself later! I recommend getting started with eHarmony, as it has the most remarkable success rate. 

Is NYC Good for Singles?

NYC isn’t known for being one of the best cities to date due to how crowded it is, but it doesn’t have to be that way. With one or more free or paid dating apps, you can find the types of connections you’re looking for in NYC without problems. 

Using a dating app to connect means you can chat freely from the comfort of your home, pick only people within your dating specifications, and choose a date without feeling too much pressure. 

Free Dating Sites in NYC 

When it comes to free dating sites in NYC, you might be wondering what you can use. As mentioned before, some of the options on our list offer free trials. 

No matter what you’re looking for, there are free dating options available. 

Rank

Site

Free Trial Link

#1

eHarmony

Join for Free

#2

Elite Singles

Join for Free

#3

Christian Cafe

Join for Free

#4

Silver Singles

Join for Free

#5

Catholic Match

Join for Free