5 Best Dating Sites in New Jersey

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 18, 2023
Couple dating in New Jersey

Online dating has made it easier to connect with someone you share interests with. So whether you’re looking for true love or companionship, there are countless dating apps and sites out there that promise to connect you with The One.

But with so many options out there, how do you know which dating site is best for you? 

After reviewing the most popular dating apps in New Jersey based on their target audience, match system, and features, I’ve put together a list of the top dating sites so you can start matching today.

Top 5 Dating Apps in New Jersey

Let’s have a look at the best dating sites and apps in New Jersey!

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


Talk about impressive. There are over 29 million users for eHarmony in the United States alone, and the success stories speak for themselves. eHarmony’s large member base has a nearly 50/50 gender split and is most popular with singles between 25-34 and 35-44.

Countless singles have made a deep and lasting connection through eHarmony’s thorough 70-question personality quiz, which matches you with other users who share your interests and goals.

All you need to do is answer honestly about yourself, and eHarmony’s matching system will do the hard work for you.

eHarmony guarantees that you’ll meet someone with who you can connect. It remains the best dating site available for singles looking for serious relationships.

eHarmony is available on Apple and Android as well as desktop.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


EliteSingles attracts highly educated, working professionals between the ages of 30 - 55 who are looking for a serious relationship. In fact, 85% of users hold an above-average degree.

With 381,000 registered users and more joining every month, EliteSingles is one of the largest dating sites that has a strong emphasis on education and work life.

EliteSingles’ matchmaking system is built with a comprehensive personality test that assesses factors such as age, location, interests, partner preferences, lifestyle, and goals to help you connect with someone who shares your outlook on life.

After answering some questions about yourself and what you’re looking for, you’ll be sent daily matches. You can also search through EliteSingles’ profiles to connect with users you might not have automatically matched with.

EliteSingles is available on iOS and Android, as well as a desktop version.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

If you’re looking for someone who shares your religious background, look no further than ChristianCafe.com. ChristianCafe connects singles looking to find serious relationships and friendships with others who share their religious denomination.

With 1 million users based in the United States and 2 million users worldwide, Christian singles will be able to connect with like-minded individuals who prioritize their faith and relationship with God.

ChristianCafe has an active member base with an average of 5,000 logins every day, so you’ll be able to connect with someone immediately.

ChristianCafe also boasts a robust security system that allows users to feel safe and comfortable when making connections.

ChristianCafe is available on desktop and on Apple products. Membership pricing starts at $39.97/month.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Singles over 50

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

As one of the most effective dating sites for singles 50 and older, SilverSingles is the perfect dating site for those looking for love, lovers, or companionship.

SilverSingles matchmaking system assesses users’ personalities, location, age, and desired relationship outcome. While many SilverSingles users are searching for a deep and lasting connection, the dating site also welcomes those seeking a more mature experience.

Users can filter matches based on what type of relationship they’re looking for.

SilverSingles will send you daily matches based on the information you provide. You can also search through other users’ profiles to reach out and connect with those you haven’t automatically matched with.

SilverSingles is available on iOS and Android, as well as a desktop version. 

5. Catholic Match - Best for Faith-Based Singles

Catholic Match

Catholic Match is the largest dating site for Catholic Singles in the world. It’s endorsed by religious leaders and emphasizes matching those who are looking for a faith-based relationship and a sacramental marriage.

With countless success stories ending in marriage, Catholic Match has proven itself to be the perfect site for single Catholics who want church and faith to be a significant facet of their relationship.

Catholic Match features the ability to search for recently active profiles, which helps serious users connect quickly and easily. Users can search profiles based on shared interests, location, background, lifestyle, and more.

Users can also share how often they attend mass, liturgical preference, and other religious and political views.

Catholic Match is available on iOS and Android, as well as a desktop version. Premium membership starts at $29.99/month.


Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

eHarmony emphasizes creating deep and lasting connections between users, making it the best dating site for serious relationships. 

What is the best hookup site in New Jersey?

The best hookup site in New Jersey is AdultFriendFinder.

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in New Jersey?

For seniors 50 and over in New Jersey, SilverSingles and eHarmony are the best dating sites. 

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

eHarmony has the highest success rate of online dating sites. It has a large member base, a comprehensive personality test, and emphasizes lasting connections.

Key Takeaways For Singles in New Jersey

New Jersey skyline on the Passaic River

Singles in New Jersey have many options when it comes to finding and making meaningful connections. Because New Jersey is a geographically small state, dating site users can also expand their search to include other singles from the surrounding states.

The best dating apps in New Jersey will help connect you with other singles who share your interests, goals, and personality.

Are New Jersey’s Cities Good For Singles?

The best cities for singles in New Jersey are Jersey City and Newark. Because New Jersey borders New York and Pennsylvania, New York City and Philadelphia are also great cities for singles in the area. 

New Jersey is also an excellent location for singles due to its proximity to multiple metropolitan areas.

What City in New Jersey is Online Dating the Most Popular?

Jersey City is the most popular city in the state for online dating.

Free Dating Sites in New Jersey

All of the sites listed in this article include a free trial before membership is required. Singles can test out their preferred dating site before committing to a membership to ensure they’ll enjoy the experience. 

It’s important to note that users may not be able to message their connections for many of the free trials without paying for membership.



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match