5 Best Dating Sites in New Hampshire

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 18, 2023
list of New Hampshire Dating Sites

Online dating has a 44% success rate compared to old-fashioned methods - which isn’t something the finger waggers will be too happy to admit as you investigate the best dating sites in New Hampshire. 

Heck, even if you happen to live in a single haven like Manchester or Portsmouth, you may find traditional dating off-putting. Online dating is a more than viable option for you in that case. 

Naysayers may be surprised to learn that one of the leading dating sites, eHarmony, has led to 600,000 plus marriages. Their divorce rate is also only 3.6% compared to the national average of 50%.

Without further ado, let’s explore the best dating sites in New Hampshire!

Top 5 Dating Apps in New Hampshire

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


Are you looking for love, marriage, and a baby carriage? Then eHarmony is for you. eHarmony has been around for over 20 years and boasts a love match every 14 minutes. Isn’t that quite impressive?

The number #1 trusted dating app in the world, eHarmony helps gay and straight couples find lasting romance and companionship in a way that is all but guaranteed.

Wait -- it “is” guaranteed!

Being around for a long time has helped eHarmony craft the art of matchmaking to a near science. There is a reason why more lasting marriages have happened with eHarmony than any other dating app known to modern men.

eHarmony offers an in-depth questionnaire to match you with the most suitable individuals. Based on this, they will send you daily recommendations while giving you the freedom to decide the next step from there.

It doesn’t get much better than that. With a high-quality dating pool as well as a money-back guarantee, you have little to lose. 

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Whether you are ready to settle down or simply desire an occasional night out with an educated professional, EliteSingles has what you are looking for.

The site provides a five-factor model for matchmaking and verifies members to lower the risk of fraudulent accounts and scammers. Start off with a free basic account to upload photos, receive/send messages, and chat to check things out.

The average age of someone on EliteSingles is 33-50 years of age and consists mainly of college grads. If you are only looking for a casual hook-up “Tinder” style, this may not be the app for you. These are career-oriented individuals who are typically in a slightly higher tax bracket.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for People of Faith

Christian Cafe signup page

One of the best dating sites in New Hampshire for theists is ChristianCafe. Established in 1999, the matchmaking app boasts over 25,000 successful marriages for singles who met locally or abroad.

Like most dating sites, Christian Cafe allows users to upload images, see which singles are most compatible and search for a particular faith denomination. You can narrow a search to what their relationship goals are as well.

As an added feature, members can communicate freely on the weekends via an online meet-up. Other bonuses include blogs that offer prayers, testimonials, and faith-based dating advice.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Mature Daters

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Most dating sites seem aimed towards young men and women looking to hook up. That isn’t to say that the over 50 crowd isn’t looking for a hook-up, however, most mature adults tend to want mature relationships.

Silver Singles offers an easy-to-use interface that even the most tech-averse person could navigate. The costs of premium memberships are a lot lower than most as well. A three-month subscription costs roughly $113.00, a six-month, $131, and an annual, $239.

Silver singles also provide the same essential services, such as uploading pictures, extensive search options, and the ability to reach out to people who interest you. With a free basic membership, it is worth a look-see.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Singles

Catholic Match

Most religious sites cater to various denominations, but, as the name implies, Catholic Singles singularly focuses on people of the Catholic faith. This is especially beneficial if you don’t wish to wade through different faith categories to find your perfect match.

Many of the features are similar to ones seen elsewhere, including subscription packages that fit just about any budget. You can upload pictures, exchange messages and enhance searches.

The largest Catholic dating site on the internet, it is endorsed by numerous catholic leaders. Not very many religious dating sites boast a thumbs up from the faith-based community itself. Impressive!


Which dating site has the highest success rate? 

eHarmony maintains its lead with matches that lead to marriage. 71% of women and 69 % of men met their posse on eHarmony within a year. It is also responsible for 4% of US marriages.

What is the best hookup site in New Hampshire? 

Surprise, surprise, it isn’t Tinder. If you are looking to hook up with a real human being and get your freak on, Adult Friend Finder is your surest bet in New Hampshire.

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in New Hampshire?

While Silver Singles and Elite Singles have a terrific array of subscriptions options and features, eHarmony tops most of the Best Dating Sites in New Hampshire lists for the 50 plus crowd. 

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

eHarmony, Elite Singles, and Silver Singles appear to be in a three-way tie regarding successfully used dating apps in New Hampshire. Check them out to see which one offers the tools needed to find your life partner.

Free Dating Sites in New Hampshire

beautiful view of a city in New Hampshire

Finding the best dating sites in New Hampshire may feel like a daunting enterprise, but it is well worth it. There are a few free dating apps for New Hampshire singles that you can peruse; just bear in mind you get what you pay for. A good dating app allows you to narrow down a search to find someone with similar goals and interests. 

The modern digital matchmaker should offer city-specific searches as well. For dating apps in New Hampshire, you want to locate and engage with individuals who understand the local culture. 

By being city-specific, singles in Laconia, Concord, or Rochester are likely to find someone in the same area.

Another great attribute of a dating app or site is the ease of use and the cost. Thankfully most sites offer a free trial or guarantee, enabling dating singles to find one that works for their current lifestyle.

The below list of the most popular dating apps in New Hampshire has these attributes and more. I have broken them down into categories so you can decide which one is your perfect fit.

All of the below sites offer a free trial to their members so that you can try them with minimal risk. A few even provide free memberships with the option to upgrade to premium subscriptions if you like their setup. 



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

Final Words

The only real difference between organic and online dating today is how a couple meets. That said, when using dating apps in New Hampshire, you may engage in the same dating rituals your folks did back in the day.