5 Best Dating Sites in Indianapolis

By: Michele Baird
Updated: February 3, 2023
Couple dating in Indianapolis

To Indianapolis residents looking for love: Never fear. The best dating sites in Indianapolis are sure to help you find that one special person you’ve been looking for. 

These five dating sites have something for everyone. If you think your situation is too specific or your standards are too high, rest assured that these dating sites will help you find your missing puzzle piece.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Indianapolis

Here are the top five dating sites in Indianapolis:

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is the best dating site available in Indianapolis. Their satisfaction guarantee is a huge boon to their success. If you’re unhappy with your matches in the first three months, they’ll provide another three-month membership at no additional charge.

One of the reasons eHarmony has the most success out of any online dating site is because the applicant pool is so large. With so many users, Indianapolis residents are sure to find someone perfect for them within city limits and beyond.

eHarmony’s matchmaking algorithm is one of the most sophisticated on the market, and it’s been tested and fine-tuned for over a decade. The algorithm can pair you with people whose values, lifestyles, and relationship goals align with yours by completing a membership questionnaire.

Best of all: People on eHarmony are ready for a commitment. Whether that means long-term dating, marriage, or starting a family, eHarmony can match you with someone who shares your relationship outlook. 

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


Elite Singles boasts one of the most educated membership bases on the online dating scene. If you take pride in your education or are currently pursuing an advanced degree, Elite Singles is the place to meet other educated singles.

If you’re educated, dating can be especially difficult. Any time spent pursuing higher education will introduce you to extraordinary people, and your standards for a match will increase as a result. If you’re not impressed with the average bear or want to date someone who also slogged through a dissertation process, Elite Singles is the dating site for you. 

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Christian and looking for God’s perfect match for you? Try ChristianCafe.com! Dating in the faith community can be difficult, especially if the dating pool at your small church is beginning to dry up. Meet someone outside of your congregation by joining ChristianCafe.com.

ChristianCafe.com provides a filtering tool so that you can match with people who are a part of your denomination. But, if you’re non-denominational, or you’re interested in meeting Christians who are outside of your specific faith group, you can also widen your search to match with any denomination!

To find someone whose faith is as important to them as it is to you, check out ChristianCafe.com.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

If you’re a part of Indianapolis’s vibrant 50+ community and you’re interested in trying online dating, give SilverSingles a try! One of the best online dating sites for seniors and singles over 50, SilverSingles is sure to please.

SilverSingles features an age filter tool so that you can target matches in your specified age range. If you’re in your 70s and only looking for other septuagenarians and up, you can filter out the spring chickens to ensure that you’re only matching with your generation.

On SilverSingles, the user base is just like you: wisened with experience, ready for adventure, and looking for love!

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Catholic Match is a tried-and-true online dating site for Catholics everywhere, and Indy Catholics will be thrilled with their vast membership pool.

Dating as a Catholic is complicated. It’s hard to find someone whose faith is compatible with yours, and trying to find someone in your local diocese can be tricky (especially in a major metropolis like Indianapolis).

But, Catholic Match can introduce you to Catholics in your area and beyond. The Catholic dating pool is more expansive than you think!

Frequently Asked Questions

When considering online dating, especially for the first time, you’re bound to have questions. Let’s explore some of the most frequently asked questions about the dating sites in Indianapolis!

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony is the dating site with the highest success rate. Their sophisticated algorithm, huge membership base, and match satisfaction guarantee all lead to successful long-term relationships. 

You simply can’t go wrong with eHarmony, especially if you’re looking for a committed relationship. eHarmony has the best success rate out of any of the dating sites, and you can become a part of those statistics by joining the site!

What is the Best Hookup Site in Indianapolis?

If you’re only in Indianapolis for a short time, or if you’re not looking to settle down just yet, try Adult Friend Finder. Everyone on Adult Friend Finder is there for the same reason: to find a hookup. If that’s your goal, too, this is the site for you!

What is the Best Dating Site for Over 50 or Seniors in Indianapolis?

The best dating sites for people over 50 and seniors in Indianapolis are eHarmony and SilverSingles. eHarmony caters to everyone over 18, including more seasoned members of the dating pool. 

SilverSingles is tailored explicitly for the 50+ demographic, and seniors looking for love gather there seeking their perfect match. If you’re over 50 and ready to take the plunge, try eHarmony or SilverSingles!

Which Dating Site is Best for Serious Relationships?

eHarmony is full of people looking for a serious relationship, whether that means long-term dating, marriage, or starting a family. If you’re tired of flakes and one-night stands, eHarmony matches will be a breath of fresh air. 

Yes, there are people in the dating pool who want commitment, and eHarmony is the place to start your next serious relationship!

Key Takeaways for Singles in Indianapolis

Indianapolis at night

If you’re single in Indianapolis, try out any of these five online dating sites to find your match. You won’t be disappointed! Let’s review each dating site and its perks:

  • eHarmony is the best overall and is the place to find people who are ready to commit.
  • Elite Singles is perfect for the educated dater, with their highly educated membership pool.
  • ChristianCafe.com can help Indy Christians find the person God made just for them.
  • SilverSingles is the place to go for 50+ dating.
  • Catholic Match takes the complication out of dating in Catholicism.

Is Indianapolis Good for Singles?

Yes! As a major metropolis, Indianapolis is full of people of diverse ages, races, and relationship goals, making it an ideal place to be single. There’s plenty of fish in the sea, and Indianapolis is perfect for fishing!

Free Dating Sites in Indianapolis

Are you looking for free online dating? Every dating site above offers a free trial. What’s better than trying before you buy? If you’re interested in all five sites, try the free trial for all of them and choose the one that suits your needs.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Indianapolis:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match

It’s Time to Start Dating in Indianapolis!

What are you waiting for? Now that you’re armed with the five best dating sites in Indianapolis, you’re ready to take the dating world by storm.

Whether you only choose to match locally or widen your horizons, these dating apps in Indianapolis will help you find your perfect match in no time.