5 Best Dating Sites in Indiana

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 11, 2023
Popular Indiana Dating Sites

Dating sites are becoming the number-one way for people to meet, but it's hard to know which ones to trust because there are so many.

As someone who has used several dating apps over the years, I've concluded which ones I can recommend the most. Here, I want to talk about five of the best dating sites in Indiana that have the highest success rates.

I should clarify that not every dating app I recommend will work for everyone. 

For example, you might only want to try ChristianCafe if you're looking to meet a Christian or if the religious preference is important to you in a potential partner.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Indiana

Below, you'll find a few critical details about each site.

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is the number-one-rated dating app for many people, myself included.

It's probably best, though, if you're looking for a serious relationship that leads to marriage or a life-long partnership.

I like eHarmony because it's quite thorough and not at all random. You get matches based on your answers to various personality questions, and you can review new matches every day. 

You'll be able to see both your matches' Compatibility Score and personality profiles for review. 

Honestly, that's par the course of any dating site, but eHarmony takes it a step further. They have a blog covering dating advice for all races and religions, making the process more interactive.

eHarmony goes in-depth with dating, giving you all kinds of communication opportunities, as well as icebreakers if you don't know how to start a conversation.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


While I think that's a bit of a pompous name for a dating site, Elite Singles is great for people aged 30-55 dating only in America. 

Interestingly, it highly promotes its "professional dating" path, where you meet professionals with career goals, which I'm not sure other dating sites have.

The matching process is similar to several other sites, with new daily matches and a compatibility quiz for best match results. 

I think if you're a corporate professional, you might find the most success with Elite Singles, but it's worth a try for people who enjoy specific dating niches, like rich dating.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Trying my first religion-based dating site was quite a gamble, especially since Christian Cafe's goal seems to be about marriages rather than long-term partnerships. 

However, I will give Christian Cafe credit for offering a 10-day free trial of their premium plan before asking people to buy a membership.

That said, it's still a Christian-based dating app, with emphasis on church denomination, amount of church involvement, and even level of Christian faith. 

It does have the usual perks of a decent algorithm with daily matches, but I'd only recommend it if religion is vital in a partner.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

SilverSingles is not the best-known dating app, perhaps because no one gives much attention to singles over 50 years old. 

I didn't test to see if they would not take a profile for someone under 50 years old, but that seems to be the age SilverSingles aims for. Nonetheless, what I saw looks pretty solid.

What's refreshing about SilverSingles is that they seem to value connection: not marriage, not romance, just companionship. 

Their magazine also takes some of the guesswork out of dating after 50. Their blog has advice and ideas for making the most of dating

While there is room for pictures in your profile, the site emphasizes your personality and interests.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

If you're looking for a relationship that ends in marriage, Catholic Match might help most with that. Catholic values bleed into every aspect of the site, from a sacramental marriage to children, so if you see those in your future, you're sure to find like-minded people.

The site is also the least expensive of any religion-based site I've looked at. That's because it's a small company and they also offer discounts to long-time customers.

Similar to Christian Cafe, you might like it best if Catholic values are essential to you. You'll also have to stay active on the site because they start deleting profiles after six months of inactivity. 

They seem to take website security very seriously. Besides the regular internet scammer, they like to weed out people who don't seem to promote Catholic values.


I'd quickly like to answer a few more questions before I go.

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

While you can find a potentially serious relationship on any dating app, I think eHarmony or Elite Singles would be your best pick. They have detailed personality quizzes, and their algorithms are pretty spot-on.

What is the best hookup site in Indiana?

Adult Friend Finder would be my recommendation for the best hookup site in Indiana. It's one website that encourages casual relationships. It also gives you the option to choose more serious matches if you're not looking for a potential hookup. 

While you're not guaranteed to find a hookup, Adult Friend Finder's more open-ended mindset on relationships means you're most likely to find one there.

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in Indiana?

You might have seen this coming, but SilverSingles is the best dating site for people over 50. It has the most users, so you're most likely to meet someone there. SilverSingles also has the most detailed personality quiz upon creating an account.

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

Once again, eHarmony gets my pick for this question. They put a lot of effort into marketing, so more people may see it, and you cannot fault a polished algorithm.

Key Takeaways for Singles in Indiana

skyline over Monument Circle

It might sound like cliche advice, but there's a dating app out there for you. You just have to decide what you value most and where you think you'll get the most significant results.

Are you looking to date someone with great professional ambition? Maybe you're looking to date someone who has money or Christian values. Perhaps you hold certain things in high regard, like politics or whether you plan to start a family.

Dating apps prioritize different things, whether it's religion, age, goals, etc. Decide what you want in a partner, and odds are, there's an app that values that too.

Are Indiana’s Cities Good for Singles?

In my experience, Indiana cities are fantastic for singles. You can easily find many interesting individuals, mainly because it's such a diverse city. If you're looking to try new places or foods with a potential date, your options are pretty wide open.

Free Dating Sites in Indiana

Some of the most popular dating apps in Indiana that also have free trials or memberships:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match