5 Best Dating Sites in Milwaukee

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 30, 2023
Couple dating in Milwaukee

Finding someone for a long-term relationship in Milwaukee can be difficult. Maybe, you considered trying dating websites in Milwaukee, only to find there are too many to choose from and a wide variance in reviews.

In my quest to find quality dating sites, I noticed a few great options that cater to certain types of relationships or demographics of singles. I prefer a simple, easy-to-use interface and an excellent profile assessment that provides the closest match possible.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Milwaukee

No matter what you’re looking for in a partner, you’ll be able to find it with one of these popular dating sites!

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is a well-known dating site with a solid reputation for results. 

Why do I rate eHarmony above the rest? It’s a secure, well-monitored dating site that focuses primarily on serious relationships and singles looking for marriage. 

There are a few other notable reasons to consider eHarmony as your primary dating site:

  • Video dating is a relatively new feature for premium members, which allows you to go on a virtual date on your desktop or dating app.

  • eHarmony routinely removes fake accounts or members who use abusive language to maintain a high quality of singles.

  • There’s a lot of information provided to help get conversations started. 

The matching process is accurate, and it’s your best bet to find a partner since it has such an extensive network of people, including Christians and seniors.

eHarmony offers a well-established platform and lots of options to meet other singles at a level of comfort suited for everyone.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


If you’re looking for a professional single, you’ll find a quality network on this dating site. Elite Singles focuses on educated singles who want to meet someone with clear objectives and goals. 

When I visited this site, I found the profiles were well-reviewed, and most singles have a university degree.

Elite Singles attracts singles who are looking for a long-term relationship, and you’ll find the free trial helpful in gauging if this dating service works for you. 

I found the pricing a bit higher than average, though it’s a good option if you want to skip dating sites that don’t adequately monitor fake or suspicious profiles.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Christian singles will find ChristianCafe.com provides a dating service specially designed for long-term relationships leading to marriage.

The website is compatible with Android and iOS users, offering a great mobile app and desktop services. ChristianCafe.com features a 10-day free trial, which gives you a chance to see if the dating site is best for you.

I found some decent benefits on the site, including sending private messages, performing a manual search, participating in forums to share your opinions, prayers, and getting to know people in a group setting.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

When you sign up on most dating sites, you’ll find the demographic is usually between 25 to 45. Silver Singles offers you all the benefits of online dating, with a focus on finding someone over 50.

The website is similar to other familiar dating services, with a compatible mobile app and platform that is easy to use.

One of the best qualities of this site is the concise nature of the questionnaire, which makes it easy to find singles who best match your interests. I think it’s a worthwhile option for anyone who wants to socialize or mingle, whether you’re looking for a serious relationship or friendship.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

Catholic Match is one of the most extensive dating services devoted to people of the Catholic faith who are serious about finding a lifetime partner for marriage.

When you first join, you will answer a series of specific questions to ensure all members are serious about finding a person of their faith.

I found the specific nature of this site offers a significant advantage because it narrows down your choices for finding a compatible match while giving you access to lots of singles.

The dating service will provide an additional six months free if you don’t find a match within the first six months of signing up.


Are you wanting to know more about dating in Milwaukee? I’ve got you covered.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony has the highest success rate for finding quality long-term relationships. 71% of women and 69% of men who use eHarmony end up meeting their spouse within a year of joining the site.

What Is the Best Hookup Site in Milwaukee?

I recommend AdultFriendFinder as the best way to find a more casual date in Milwaukee. AdultFriendFinder is one of the best options in Milwaukee to find companionship without the pressure of commitment.

What Is the Best Dating Site for Over 50 or Seniors in Milwaukee?

eHarmony and Silver Singles offer the most dating options if you’re over 50 or a senior in Milwaukee.

eHarmony is for all singles and has a database of over 10 million people, which makes it easier to find a match. However, Silver Singles is exclusively for the over-50 or senior dater.

Which Dating Site is Best for Serious relationships?

If you are looking for a serious relationship, eHarmony is your best choice. The survey questions you answer when you sign up for eHarmony ensure a match with someone looking for the same relationship type that you are.

Key Takeaways for Singles in Milwaukee

Milwaukee city on Lake Michigan at twilight

It can be a challenge looking for love online at any age. Even though there’s not one app specifically for senior Christians, Senior Christians looking for love in Milwaukee still have many options. 

As more people sign up for online dating, you’ll find a lot more singles to meet and the need for greater convenience and features, such as video dating, communities, and private messaging.

A quality dating service will offer the best match possible, with quality singles and great opportunities to explore a meaningful relationship. I’ve included a list of the five best dating sites in Milwaukee to help get you started.

Here’s a quick rundown of what the dating sites in Milwaukee have to offer:

  • eHarmony has the largest number of members and is geared toward singles who are looking for a long-term relationship.
  • Elite Singles can help you find a well-educated, professional single to date.
  • Christian Cafe can help you find a long-term Christian relationship. 
  • Silver Singles focuses on over-50 daters, so you don’t have to weed through younger daters.
  • Catholic Match connects Catholic daters who are looking for marriage.

Is Milwaukee Good for Singles?

Only 32% of Milwaukeeans are married, so Milwaukee is a good place to find singles. 

However, most Milwaukeeans are below 50. Because Milwaukee is a young city, it may be more difficult to find love above age 50. Only 14% of single men and women are between 50 and 60. And only 6% of single men and 7% of single women are 60 to 65.

Dating apps in nearby cities:

Most Popular Dating Apps in Madison

Free Dating Sites in Milwaukee

Not all of the dating sites in Milwaukee are free dating sites. Most are free to join, but you have to pay for premium features.

Also, most free dating sites contain a massive number of fake accounts and scammers, so it's better to try a premium site by taking advantage of the free trial.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Milwaukee:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match