5 Best Dating Sites in San Antonio

By: Michele Baird
Updated: March 25, 2022
Couple dating in San Antonio

If you’re anything like me, you don’t have a lot of time to waste on dating sites that get you nowhere. Personally, I need a website that I can navigate quickly and that I can trust to present me with quality people to meet.

I recently spent time evaluating several dating sites in San Antonio. The ability to go online and meet people specifically matched up to me based on my compatibility profile appealed to me.

I found that different sites are best for different things. For example, some websites are best for those looking for serious prospects, and others are best for meeting singles over 50 or casual hookups. 

If you’re looking for the top dating sites in San Antonio, look no further. Here are my top picks:

Top 5 Dating Sites In San Antonio

There are numerous online dating options, but I’ve narrowed it down to five.

1. eHarmony - Best Overall

eHarmony

When it comes to finding suitable matches quickly, eHarmony takes the prize. It’s established, easy to navigate, and has an excellent reputation.

eHarmony is my number one choice for a few reasons. Not only was it rated 2020 #1 trusted dating site in the US, UK, Canada, and Australia, but it’s the best choice for those looking for a serious relationship.

In my experience, eHarmony is filled with people who take dating seriously. People on eHarmony are looking for long-term relationships or marriage. While the members are ethnically, racially, and religiously diverse, the largest subcategories include people over 50 years old or those looking for a Christian partner.

Whether you fall into those categories or not, the chances of you finding your true match are high. The vast majority of people on eHarmony -- 71% of women and 69% of men, to be exact -- meet their match within one year. That’s all it takes, just one year.

You can join for free or upgrade to a premium membership; eHarmony offers a guarantee that you’ll be satisfied with your matches in three months -- or you’ll get an additional three months free.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall

EliteSingles.com

EliteSingles distinguishes itself as the site for those looking for professional people to date. It prides itself on catering to all races, religions, ages, and sexual orientations.
If you’re finding it difficult to find educated and motivated people, EliteSingles may be for you. According to their website, 85% of registrants are highly educated. The majority are successful, single professionals aged 30 to 55.

With approximately 381,000 new members per month, the EliteSingles website and app are designed to be safe and secure.

EliteSingles offers free and premium memberships. Upon joining, you’ll receive EliteSingles Magazine, which provides tips for dating and finding someone special.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

This Christian-owned site is all single and all Christian. The site has been around since 1999 and claims over 25,000 marriages.

Whether you’re a young adult, divorced, widowed, or over 50, you can meet others who share your faith and values.

One of the things I liked about ChristianCafe.com was the forums. In the forums and group chat rooms, I found fellowship through group conversations and was able to pick up a few tips for navigating the site.

I also liked the uplifting testimonials posted on the website about people who met on the site. To learn more, check out their free 10-day trial.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

SilverSingles specializes in matching up people ages 50 and up. Like other sites, you take a compatibility test to get paired up with people with similar goals and values.

SilverSingles lets you filter for mature dating, gay senior dating, and older women dating. You can read about other singles who are signed up.

With a free basic membership, you are able to complete the personality test and set up a profile. You will also receive recommended profiles, but with limited communications with other members.

The paid premium membership gives you full use of the features available on the site, including unlimited access to other profiles and unlimited communication with other premium members.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

If you’re looking for Catholic faith-focused dating leading to marriage, CatholicMatch is worth checking out.

The site provides tips for living more fully as a single person and dating more purposefully and offers support for Catholics looking for relationships leading to marriage. A free trial membership is available.

CatholicMatch claims it has the most Catholics of any dating website and prides itself on giving you the opportunity to meet other Catholics who value their faith.

You can browse for conservative, liberal, traditional, young adult, Hispanic, over 50, and other Catholic singles.

FAQs

Now let me share with you some of the questions I had when I began reviewing the sites.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony has one of the highest success rates for long-term love: almost three-quarters of the members met their spouse on eHarmony within the first year of using it.

Studies have shown that more than 500 people get married daily after meeting on eHarmony.

What is the Best Hookup Site in San Antonio?

Not after a relationship? If you’re looking for casual sex only, AdultFriendFinder is probably your best bet.

This site specializes in matching up people who want hookup relationships. It’s suited for singles, swingers, or discreet meetups. Fees range around $24.95 per month.

What is the Best Dating Site for Over 50 or Seniors in San Antonio?

eHarmony’s compatibility quiz improves your chances of finding someone special. Because many of the people on eHarmony are serious about dating, your chances of finding someone over the age of 50 are greater.

SilverSingles is another good option for meeting seniors. Because it markets itself as the exclusive site for those over age 50, it gets a lot of internet traffic and online interest.

Which Dating Site is Best for Serious Relationships?

Here again, eHarmony is the winner. Most of the people on eHarmony are serious about finding meaningful relationships.

eHarmony quizzes you on your communication style, personality, how you behave in relationships, and your everyday life. Its sophisticated algorithms match you up with people you have the best chances of connecting with.

Key Takeaways for Singles in San Antonio

It can be overwhelming to start out in the online dating world, but keep the benefits in mind and follow these three tips – you’ll be up and running in no time!

  • Online dating sites are fast and effective ways to meet like-minded singles -- take advantage of them.
  • Review the online options available -- some specialize in long-term relationships, faith-based dating leading to marriage, over 50 dating, and others.
  • Know what is free and what you’re paying for -- most online sites offer a free membership or a premium paid membership.

Is San Antonio Good for Singles?

In my experience, yes! And online dating sites make the process of dating even more manageable. 

Free Dating Sites In San Antonio

eHarmony, Elite Singles, ChristianCafe.com, SilverSingles, and CatholicMatch all offer free memberships or free trials.

You can try any of these dating sites without paying, so what do you have to lose? Give online dating a chance. You won’t regret it!

Rank

Site

Free Trial Link

#1

eHarmony

Join for Free

#2

Elite Singles

Join for Free

#3

Christian Cafe

Join for Free

#4

Silver Singles

Join for Free

#5

Catholic Match

Join for Free