5 Best Dating Sites in South Dakota

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 21, 2023
Couple dating in South Dakota

Dating is hard, and living in South Dakota can also impact your ability to connect with others. The state's less-than-a-million population can seem tiny, and looking for a date can be a daunting task when it's almost like there's nobody out there.

Thankfully, there are online dating sites. A lot of them, for basically any and every need. 

Top 5 Dating Apps in South Dakota

If you're looking for love in 2024, below are the best dating sites in South Dakota:

1. eHarmony - Best Overall


eHarmony is the most well-known dating site for a reason. It works. Boasting that members find love every 14 minutes, this site is perfect for those looking for a soulmate. 

One of the main benefits of eHarmony is the community. eHarmony spans more than 190 countries, so you don’t have to stick to just South Dakota residents (unless that’s what you’re into). 

Other benefits of eHarmony include:

  • Personalized dating experience
  • Algorithm-based matching 
  • Flexible membership plans

eHarmony does offer free memberships, but most people find the paid plans are worth it. 

Basic Plan

  • Send and receive Smiles, Icebreakers, and Greetings
  • Anonymously browse the site
  • See who viewed your profile

Premium Plan

The Premium plan becomes an option after you are a member of eHarmony, and the memberships vary in length. You also get:

  • Unlimited matches
  • Video dating
  • Ability to view photos

If you’re serious about dating, eHarmony is your best bet. Other members are paying for their memberships, so you can have confidence that they’re in it for the real deal, too.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall


If you’re into smarties, EliteSingles is the dating site for you. 

The site states that 85% of its members are highly educated, so if you’re looking to have intellectually stimulating conversations with someone over a glass of wine, EliteSingles might have the right person. 

Like eHarmony, EliteSingles offers a basic plan for free and a premium plan. Both plans include: 

  • A scientifically created personality profile
  • Match suggestions
  • Receiving messages
  • Ability to upload photos

The premium membership offers more extensive options, such as unlimited messaging, a mobile app, and a read receipt feature. 

One of the benefits separating EliteSingles from its competitors is the “Have You Met…” feature. It allows you to browse potential partners who are outside of your suggestions.

So, if you’re a single person in Rapid City who’s moving to Sioux Falls and EliteSingles doesn’t recommend anyone from that location, you can search for them yourself!

EliteSingles’ premium plan is $57.95/month for a three-month plan, $44.95/month for a six-month plan, and $31.95/month for a 12-month plan.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

Almost 59% of South Dakota residents affiliate themselves with a Christian denomination. 

If you’re one of those people looking for a religious partner, Christian Cafe can help you find your perfect match!

Christian Cafe provides specific location searching, so finding other Christian singles in South Dakota is a breeze.

Additional benefits of this site are forums and Post a Prayer, which allows for community engagement, and a free seven-day trial. 

What sets this dating site apart from others the most, though, is its payment options. Christian Cafe is affordable and has flexible plans to meet your needs. 

Payment plans are as follows: 

  • Six months unlimited access: $107.95
  • Three months unlimited access: $69.97
  • One month unlimited access: $44.97
  • Two weeks unlimited access: $34.97

If you’re budget-conscious and looking for a partner who shares your faith, Christian Cafe might be the best option.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

Young at heart and looking for your happily ever after? SilverSingles is here to help. 

Find other South Dakota singles who are older than 50 without the hassle of a filter or swiping. 

SilverSingles also offers adventures that are exclusive to members and allow you to interact with other singles.

Some other benefits of SilverSingles include: 

  • Detailed personality profile for the best matches
  • Strict age policy means you have a safe and welcoming community
  • Easy to use

Like its counterparts, SilverSingles offers several pricing options. 

SilverSingles has a free trial option that allows you to check out everything and get a feel for the site. The only pitfall to this tier is that you cannot see user photos. 

A 12-month subscription to SilverSingles is $27.95/month, a six-month membership is $37.95/month, and a three-month membership is $49.95.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

If you’re one of the 22% of South Dakota residents who is Catholic and single looking for love, Catholic Match is the perfect dating site for you!

Catholic Match offers faith-focused dating and supports its members through their journey of finding love.

While this dating site might already seem pretty niche, it offers an even more specific dating profile, allowing members to describe their faith in detail to other Catholics and the particulars of their belief systems. 

Things to note about Catholic Match: 

  • Focused on marriage only; no hookups here
  • Website content is monitored by customer service representatives daily 
  • Supports the Catholic church through events 

Catholic Match is very affordable compared to some other sites. It offers monthly subscriptions starting at $29.99 and six-month subscriptions starting at $79.95. 

Annual subscriptions are available during special promotions only.


Are you still questioning online dating in South Dakota? Below are frequently asked questions from other singles.

Which Dating Site Has The Highest Success Rate?

eHarmony. Since its inception, the platform has been responsible for 4% of U.S. marriages.

What is the Best Hookup Site in South Dakota?

If something casual is more your speed, Adult Friend Finder is a good option. It’s the largest hookup site on the web and is for casual dating or swingers.

What City in South Dakota Has the Most Active Online Dating Scene?

Vermillion singles have the most interest in online dating, and Springfield residents have the least. 

Key Takeaways for Singles in South Dakota

South Dakota Panorama view

Are you looking for long-lasting love with your soulmate? There's an app for that. 

Are you searching for something casual and more hookup-oriented? You're covered.

Are you unsure and looking for something in the middle? No problem. 

Love doesn’t have to be scary. It really shouldn’t be! 

Online dating is the way of life in 2024, and that goes for South Dakota singles as well. 

If you’re putting yourself out there and just not getting the results you want, try one of the sites above. If anything, you can gain confidence and experience. 

Finding love after 2020 might not be easy, but if there’s one thing the pandemic taught us, it’s to value personal relationships. Your soulmate could be just a click away.

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in South Dakota:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match