5 Best Dating Sites in Illinois

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 11, 2023
Popular Illinois Dating Sites

The world of online dating can be daunting. Putting yourself out there, creating the perfect profile, and sorting through what can seem like endless profiles can feel like drudgery. But dating is supposed to be fun!

Fortunately, we’ve taken the hard work out of selecting the right online dating option for Illinois singles by identifying Illinois’ top 5 dating sites.

Top 5 Dating Apps in Illinois

Whether you’re looking for a long-term match, someone with similar values, or those in a life stage similar to yours, you’ll find the right site for you among this top 5 list.

1. eHarmony


With innovative matching algorithms and an impressive match success rate, it’s no wonder why this is the top dating site in Illinois.

Among eHarmony’s benefits are:

  • The site uses comprehensive user information and highly accurate personality profiles to make sure you match with the best potential mates.

  • While you need to enter a lot of personal information on eHarmony, the site keeps all of your information safe and secure so you can use it to date with confidence.

  • You can access eHarmony from just about any device, including your phone, smart device, or the browser on your desktop.

eHarmony is the number one site in Illinois because of its unique and powerful matching system. Unlike other sites, you won’t have to browse through endless profiles on eHarmony. Rather, eHarmony will only show you potential dates with whom you have the best match based on your answers to personal questions.

What’s more, eHarmony offers a user satisfaction guarantee. If you are not satisfied with the matches you receive through eHarmony within the first three months, you will receive an additional three months at no cost to you.

eHarmony is best for those looking for a serious, committed relationship that might ultimately lead to marriage. The site is responsible for approximately 2% of all new marriages in the U.S.

2. Elite Singles


This dating site is designed specifically with educated professionals in mind. If education, income, and a hearty work ethic are important to you, Elite Singles may be exactly the site you need. With 170,000 active users, it’s no surprise that Elite Singles ranks second among Illinoisans looking for a dating match.

 Among Elite Singles’ benefits, you’ll find:

  • You’re most likely to be matched with those who are well educated and financially successful.

  • Over 90% of users are over the age of 30. So, if you’re a more mature dater looking for a mature match, this site may be the right one for you.

  • The Elite Singles user questionnaire ensures you match those whose personality types and relationship styles most closely reflect yours.

On Elite Singles, you can specify what you’re looking for in a relationship to ensure you get the best matches possible. You can see the answers of your potential matches, allowing you to do some vetting of your own as well as find some great fodder for conversation starters.

3. Christian Cafe

Christian Cafe signup page

Designed especially for Christian singles from various denominations, ChristianCafe ranks third among Illinois’ top dating sites. 

ChristianCafe.com offers free and premium memberships and includes an option for gifting a premium membership to another user. ChristianCafe’s benefits include:

  • Users can filter by religious beliefs, including beliefs on God, Christian denomination, and involvement with church.

  • Quick matches allow users to find other Christian singles in the Illinois area without creating an extensive search.

  • The site is available on your web browser and in the form of android and iPhone apps.

  • Members can block those with whom they wish to have no contact.

If you’re looking for Christian singles like yourself in Illinois, ChristianCafe.com may be just the right site for you. If you’re thinking about a Christian single in your life looking for a match, keep in mind that you can gift them a premium membership to help them in their search.

4. Silver Singles

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

This dating site is designed for those who are 50+ to find other senior singles. Fourth among Illinois’ top dating sites, SilverSingles boasts 800,000 users and an exclusively senior membership base.

This site, previously named PrimeSingles and Senior Singles Meet, offers many user benefits, including:

  • Unlike other dating sites, which usually have more male members, you’ll find that 59% of SilverSingles’ users are women.

  • Users can set up filters that will allow them to find the most attractive and compatible matches for them.

  • Members of SilverSeniors can browse profiles for free. Also, at no cost, members can send smiles and mark profiles as favorites.

If you’re an Illinois senior looking for love or friendship online, SilverSingles may be the perfect site for you. You can be assured that fellow singles on the site are all 50+, so your potential matches will be a senior like yourself.

5. Catholic Match

Catholic Match

Fifth among Illinois’ top dating sites, Catholic Match is designed specifically with Catholic singles in mind. If your Catholic faith is an important part of your life, finding another single like yourself can be difficult. Catholic Match allows you to match with the most compatible Catholic singles in your area.

Catholic match boasts many benefits, including:

  • This site is faith-focused and allows you to start any potential relationship with your Catholic faith at the forefront.

  • You’ll find that most members are very active on this site, responding quickly to messages and participating in discussion forums.

  • You can participate in the site for free or opt for a premium membership at $29.99 per month. Other users will not be able to tell whether you have a free or premium membership.

If you’re an Illinois single whose Catholic faith is very important to you, you’ll likely find that Catholic Match is the ideal site for you. If, on the other hand, you are not Catholic or you are Catholic but not very involved in your faith, you’ll want to opt for one of the other top dating sites.


Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

If you’re looking for something serious, your best option is eHarmony. This site is designed with serious dating seekers in mind. 

It is responsible for 2% of all marriages in the U.S. eHarmony users will find they’re matched with those with similar, serious relationship goals.

What is the best hookup site in Illinois?

If you’re looking for a hook-up rather than a relationship, your best option is Adult Friend Finder. This site is focused on those strictly looking for sex, cutting out the sometimes tedious process of discovering someone’s intentions or goals for a relationship. 

In addition to hook-ups, Adult Friend Finder is great for those interested in sexting and/or exchanging adult pictures.

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in Illinois?

If you’re 50+ and looking for other senior dating partners, you’ll want to head to SilverSingles. SilverSingles ensures all members are 50 or over, so you can be assured you’ll find matches who are seniors like yourself.

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

The answer to this question depends on how you define success. If you define success as relationships that ultimately lead to marriage, eHarmony certainly boasts the greatest success rate. 

If you define success and matching with a sexual partner, Adult Friend Finder is the most successful site. If you define success somewhere between marriage and sex, you’ll want to explore more dating apps to determine which is the most successful for you.

Key Take-Aways for Singles in Illinois

Illinois skyline at sunset

When it comes to online dating, you’ve got plenty of options in Illinois. Keep in mind that all of the top 5 dating sites in Illinois offer a free trial.

So, if you’re trying to figure out the best online dating option for you, you can give several sites a try without paying the costs of membership or premium access. Whichever option you choose, we wish you happy hunting and happy dating!

Are Illinois’ cities good for singles?

Cities in Illinois are great for singles. You’ll find more potential matches the larger the city size. Also, in cities, you’re likely to find many exciting activities to keep your dates interesting and fun.

Free Dating Sites in Illinois

Here are the free trial links for the most popular dating apps in Illinois:



Free Trial Link




Elite Singles


Christian Cafe


Silver Singles


Catholic Match