5 Best Dating Sites in San Francisco

By: Michele Baird
Updated: March 29, 2022
Couple dating in San Francisco

With a population of approximately 880,000 people, dating in San Francisco can feel hopeless. The big and busy city is tiresome as it is. Add finding companionship to the mix, and you’re in for a treat. 

Well, trust me when I say meeting someone special isn’t as hard as you think. I compiled a list of the best dating sites in San Francisco to guide you.

San Franciscan singles are usually on the prowl for love, casually looking, or simply testing the waters. Regardless of your motives, one of the following dating sites will meet your needs. 

Top 5 Dating Sites in San Francisco 

1. eHarmony - Best Overall

eHarmony

eHarmony was the first algorithm-based dating site. The now trademarked method has helped over two million singles find love. With that said, the site is perfect for anyone desiring a serious and long-term commitment.

eHarmony is my front-runner because they invest in your journey. If you’re not satisfied within the first three months, they provide an additional free three months.

I also appreciate how eHarmony takes the pain out of finding an authentic connection.

Users start with a quiz that analyzes 32 compatibility dimensions of their personality. eHarmony then provides a list of matches, each complete with a compatibility score.

This method has proven especially beneficial for single Christians and seniors. Unfortunately, just because someone’s of the same religion or age group doesn’t mean they’re your soulmate.

Most of us learned this the hard way, but eHarmony prevents that. Perhaps the reason Christian and senior eHarmony dating pools have the most members.

2. Elite Singles - Runner Up, Best Overall

EliteSingles.com

EliteSingles is great for 30 to 55-year-old educated professionals seeking a serious relationship. Over 90 percent of EliteSingles users are over 30 years old with an above-average education.

Much like eHarmony, the site determines compatibility through a detailed personality test. The EliteSingles test employs the five-factor model—a psychological process used for over 40 years old.

The in-depth model examines preferences surrounding open-mindedness, spontaneity, extroversion, temperament, sensitivity, and more. EliteSingles compares the test results to other users then handpicks matches.

You will receive 3-7 matches a day, reducing the amount of time you spend sorting potential mates. This process is perfect for a busy San Francisco single.

And yes, I get it—entrusting your love life to an algorithm is frightening. Rest assured, EliteSingles is highly secure. The site vets users with profile verification, SSL encryption, and fraud detection, ensuring your matches are trustworthy.

3. Christian Cafe - Best for Faith-Based Dating

Christian Cafe signup page

ChristianCafe.com is an international dating site with 22 years of experience in matchmaking. The site is best for Christian singles interested in building Christ-centered relationships.

The site doesn’t utilize an algorithm like eHarmony. However, varied search settings give you more control over your matches. Your search criteria can specify a location, age, denomination, participation in church, appearance, and more.

The creators also understand that Christians aren’t constantly searching for immediate love. Therefore, you can pick from curious, casual, and committed relationship preferences.

I like this site because they offer a flexible 10-day free trial. Yes, most dating sites offer a trial period but with strict conditions. ChristianCafe.com grants new users unlimited access to messaging, browsing, and participating in fellowship forums.

4. Silver Singles - Best for Senior Dating

Silversingles Online Dating Signup Page

SilverSingles is for adults 50 years or older in pursuit of a genuine connection. Spark Networks owns both SilverSingles and EliteSingles. Therefore, the sites are highly similar.

Like EliteSingles, SilverSingles’ compatibility test utilizes the five-factor model to highlight your unique characteristics.

Next, you’ll answer questions surrounding match expectations like age, kids, location, and education level. SilverSingles algorithm will then send you 3-7 matches a day.

The app is most beneficial for mature adults seeking a secure way to date online. Matches are highly compatible, frequently updated with each new user, and checked for legitimacy daily.

5. Catholic Match - Best for Catholic Dating

Catholic Match

CatholicMatch is the largest Catholic dating site in the world. It is reserved for Catholics waiting on sacramental marriage. Therefore, your chances of faith-based love drastically increase.

First, you complete a comprehensive questionnaire focusing on values, goals, characteristics, etc. CatholicMatch’s algorithm compares your answers to other members then creates a match list. You select “yes” or “no” for each match.

However, you can also search for potential matches using filters generic as age or complex as appearance.

I often recommend CatholicMatch because they highlight how faith fosters sacramental love. A portion of the process even allows you to define what faith means to you.

CatholicMatch also recognizes online dating isn’t always quick and easy. Therefore, making a genuine effort in your first six months grants you an additional six months, free.

FAQs 

Which dating site has the highest success rate?

When it comes to relationships and marriage, eHarmony has the highest success rate. Let’s be honest—any dating site with a patented algorithm is likely high-quality. 

Compared to other dating sites, eHarmony creates the most marriages. It’s also voted the number one trusted dating site. You can relax knowing you’re getting a return on your investment. 

What is the best hookup site in San Francisco?

If you’re looking for a casual hookup, try Adult FriendFinder. Regardless of your preferences, Adult FriendFinder can quickly connect you with a local hookup date. 

What is the best dating site for over 50 or seniors in San Francisco?

eHarmony and SilverSingles are perfect for San Francisco seniors looking for a high-quality partner. 

SilverSingles only permits users over 50, and eHarmony’s algorithm strictly follows provided preferences. Therefore, finding what you’re looking for won’t feel relentless. 

Which dating site is best for serious relationships?

eHarmony is known for an extensive compatibility quiz that yields high success rates. eHarmony has produced four percent of U.S. marriages. 

This isn’t surprising since most users join with the intent of commitment. And the truth is, most casual daters won’t undergo such comprehensive onboarding. 

Key Takeaways For Singles in San Francisco

San Francisco is full of diverse singles. Let’s recap each dating site’s best use. 

  • If you’re looking for a serious commitment, give eHarmony a shot. 
  • If you’re a senior in San Francisco that values genuine relationships, use eHarmony or SilverSingles. 
  • If you’re an educated professional longing for a mate of the same caliber, try EliteSingles. 
  • If you’re looking for someone to grow in faith with, sign up for eHarmony, ChristianCafe.com, or CatholicMatch. 

Remember that online dating is no longer viewed as a last resort. With nearly 45 million users, dating apps seem to be most singles’ first choice.

Is San Francisco Good For Singles?

San Francisco is the 17th largest city in the United States and one of California’s busiest cities. Long commutes and work hours make finding companionship intimidating. However, demanding city life doesn’t have to be lonely. 

I’d go as far as to say, San Francisco’s unique outing opportunities are prime for singles. If you’re having trouble meeting the right person, simplify your search with online dating. 

Free Dating Sites In San Francisco

San Francisco is known for its distinct and emboldened population. It goes without saying, a single dating site won’t fit every San Franciscan’s expectations.

Luckily, most dating apps in San Francisco offer a convenient “try before you buy” period. If you’re struggling to pick a dating site, take advantage of one of the following free trials.

Rank

Site

Free Trial Link

#1

eHarmony

Join for Free

#2

Elite Singles

Join for Free

#3

Christian Cafe

Join for Free

#4

Silver Singles

Join for Free

#5

Catholic Match

Join for Free