eHarmony vs OurTime – Which One is Better in 2022?

By: Michele Baird
Updated: January 6, 2022
OurTime versus eHarmony header

To gauge the specifics behind OurTime and eHarmony dating sites, I’ve taken the time to research what sets these two online dating platforms apart from one another.

While both platforms are reliable, trustworthy dating sites, both platforms have several key differences. 

Both websites offer mobile apps that help men and women find love using an algorithm based on personal interests, likes, and relationship preferences. 

However, the program you decide to choose depends on what you’re looking for in a dating app.

Let’s get started with the review.

Brief Overview: eHarmony vs. OurTime

Before diving straight into the comparison between the two dating sites, this section discusses the basics behind eHarmony and OurTime and their differences.  

What is eHarmony?

Established in 2000 in Los Angeles, CA, eHarmony is an online dating app/website that uses its specialized Compatibility Matching System to connect members with compatible persons with whom they are likely to have a long-term relationship.

eHarmony is one of the largest dating sites designed specifically for long-term relationships and marriage-minded singles. Each match is curated based on shared personality traits, habits, and interests. 

According to a 2020 study, eHarmony is the number one most trusted dating app in the U.S., U.K., Canada, and Australia. 

The popular dating website claims responsibility for over 500 marriages each day in the U.S., and according to their compatibility surveys, someone finds love every 14 minutes using eHarmony.

Find more about how eHarmony works on our in-depth eHarmony review here.

What is OurTime?

OurTime is a website/mobile app for people over the age of 50 looking for new, legitimate relationships. After joining for free, users can browse through matches and connect with like-minded singles.

If you're looking for a serious approach to mature online dating, OurTime dating services are a great option. The app lets users join for free, but the best features are only available with paid subscriptions, which can get quite pricey.

Which is Better, and Why?

OurTime is best for curating accurate matches amongst a mature crowd. However, the app is limited to people over the age of 50, contains numerous ads and pricey monthly subscriptions. 

With eHarmony, the accuracy of your matches depends on how detailed and honest you are with your profile and description.  

A 2018 study of more than 1,600 U.S. singles also found eHarmony to have the highest quality dating pool. For users who are willing to spend both money and time to find the right match, eHarmony is the best option. 

According to Consumer Affairs, both dating websites have the same satisfaction rating of 3.8/5.0. However, after going through many of the reviews themselves, eHarmony comes out on top as the most accurate and reliable choice, covering an extensive range of people.

Keep reading to better understand the differences between eHarmony and OurTime, and why eHarmony might be a better choice for you.

Comparing eHarmony and OurTime

Now that you’ve gained a better understanding of eHarmony and OurTime, let’s compare the two dating apps so you can determine which one might be right for you.

1. Design and Ease of Use

The overall design of eHarmony is modern, sleek, and easy to navigate. Instead of endlessly scrolling through profiles, eHarmony does the work for you, matching you with people based on compatibility. 

This reduces the amount of time spent on the app and enhances its ergonomic design. 

With eHarmony, users can have peace of mind knowing they aren't getting scammed, either. The dating website screens for sex offenders, monitors suspicious accounts, and filters out people who are only looking to hook up. 

Likewise, OurTime is considerably easy to use and offers helpful safety tips when navigating the website. Many users of OurTime praise the site specifically for its easy-to-use app interface. 

Especially since the site is designed for seniors, the features are precisely made to be easy to navigate.  

2. Accuracy

The most impressive feature of eHarmony is a psychology test based on the studies of Dr. Neil Clark Warren, who is coincidentally the dating site’s founder.

Instead of using the Tinder-type algorithm, which matches people based on physical features and attractive profiles, eHarmony turns to science to create accurate matches. 

Since you have to take the psychology test, eHarmony’s entire registration process takes some time. So to make the experience more enjoyable, eHarmony designs the test in the form of a fun, engaging quiz.

While eHarmony's questionnaire might be lengthy, it helps generate more accurate matches. 

By comparison, OurTime doesn’t feature a questionnaire. Instead, questions are optional for your profile. While this might seem easier, the chances of accurately matching with other users are lower.

Additionally, eHarmony has a user demographic of 50% men and 50% women, while OurTime is 56% male and 44% female (this data could be changed in June).

3. Pricing and Payment Methods 

With eHarmony, users can choose from three paid memberships and a free one. All of which offer different features.

The free subscription gives users access to see profile photos of other singles and send limited messages.

Next is the Premium plan, which provides a verified status, opens up secure calls, and shares more information about your psychology test to curate more accurate matches. The Premium plan gives you access to all features.

However, it's worth considering how much you're willing to spend on the dating site. The Premium Light plan is $55.90 per month and lasts six months, while the Premium Plus plan lasts 12 months, with a cost of $35.90. The Premium Extra plan costs $25.90, lasting a total of 24 months. You can know more about eHarmony membership pricing details on this page.

OurTime offers two subscription plans: monthly and semi-annual. Subscription fees start at just $15 each month. However, they heavily restrict access to features and frequently push you to upgrade your membership plan. 

Overall, eHarmony is technically more expensive, but OurTime has far fewer features unless you pay the additional subscription fee.

eHarmony vs. OurTime: Which is Best?

Using the above comparisons, distinguishing eHarmony and OurTime is simple, especially since the latter is exclusively designed for singles above the age of 50. 

Additionally, eHarmony features a considerably large user base and even offers a separate senior section for older singles.

While OurTime focuses more on senior-oriented content, eHarmony offers more features that are more appealing, higher accuracy with matching, and a more comprehensive range of profile personalization options—making this dating site a better choice.

Tried your hand at dating and looking for something serious? Check out eHarmony and create a customized profile so you can accurately match with like-minded singles.

Related eHarmony Comparison Articles: